Dnp- aqr powerpoint review for editing
If you are looking for affordable, custom-written, high-quality, and non-plagiarized papers, your student life just became easier with us. We are the ideal place for all your writing needs.
Order a Similar Paper
Order a Different Paper
I need speaker’s notes on slides 5,6,7,9,10,12,13,19,20,21,22,23,24, and 25 in the attached PowerPoint project. Please see the original assignment also in the attachment.
1
EffectivenessofAerobicExerciseonAmbulatoryBloodPressureinHypertensivePatients
Submitted by
Chinyere Christiana Pamugo
A Direct Practice Improvement Project Presented in Partial Fulfillment
Of the Requirements for the Degree
Doctor of Nursing Practice
Grand Canyon University
Phoenix, Arizona
December 7th, 2022
©byChinyereChristianaPamugo,2022
All rights reserved.
GRANDCANYONUNIVERSITY
EffectivenessofAerobicExerciseonAmbulatoryBloodPressureinHypertensivePatients
Chinyere Christiana Pamugo
Has been approved
December 7th, 2022
APPROVED:
Dawn Robinson DNP, MSN, RN, LNHA, DPI Project Chairperson
Khoa Don Nguyen, MD.,DPI Project Mentor
ACCEPTEDANDSIGNED:
________________________________________
Lisa Smith, Ph.D., RN, CNE
Dean and Professor, College of Nursing and HealthCare Professions
_________________________________________
Date
HypertensionisaprevalentdiseaseaffectingmillionsofindividualsintheUnitedStates.Attheprojectsite,therewerenostandardizedguidelinesforeducatinghypertensivepatientsregardingincorporatingexercise(dailyphysicalactivity)asabloodpressure (BP)managementmechanism.Thepurposeofthisquantitative,quasi-experimentalprojectwas to determine if or to what degree the implementation of “theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineonaerobicexercisewouldimpactambulatory bloodpressurewhencomparedtocurrentpracticeamongadulthypertensivepatientsinaprimarycareclinicinsouthwestTexasoverfourweeks.DorothyOrem’sself-caredeficittheoryandLewin’schangemodelwere the scientific underpinnings.Datawereretrievedfromtheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecords of adult hypertensive patients.(
n-10) and compared at baseline and four weeks post-implementation of the American Herat Association’s guideline on aerobic exercise. A paired-sample
t-test showed a statistically and clinically significant improvement in the systolic blood pressure. Based on the results, the American Herat Association’s guideline on aerobic exercise may improve blood pressure.Onerecommendationforfutureprojectsistoconducttheprojectinothermedicalsettingssuchasmedical-surgicalunits,women’shealth,anddialysispatients.
Keywords:aerobicexercise,AmericanHeartAssociationguideline,DorothyOrem’sself-caredeficittheory,hypertension,hypertension-relatedconditions,KurtLewin’changemodel.
I dedicate this project to God, my life’s author, and finisher. Irrespective of the unsurmountable challenges and moments of despair, your mercy, grace, and love lead me through. Without your divine wisdom, Almighty father, I would not have been here this day.
To my Beloved families here and abroad, my mum, siblings, cousins, and spouse Engr. G. O. Pamugo, I achieved this goal because of your fervent prayers, support, and encouragement that fortified my strength, endurance, perseverance, and resilience not to quit to frustrations and fears. Even with my poor health, I struggled and still made it to this day because you all held my weak parts as I journeyed and ran the race to success. Thank you for believing in me and investing in my success. God bless you all. To my dad-late Chief M.E. Chukwu, I did accomplish your dreams on me, and I know wherever your soul is at this time, it is full of joy; rest in peace, daddy, until we meet again.
To my elder brother in the Lord, Rev. Fr. C. Iwuagwu, words cannot express the magnitude of gratitude I owe you for your fatherly and brotherly love, belief in my abilities, countless hours of encouragement, enormous -uplifts, and renewed determination. You are a blessing and gift to our family; remain blessed.
Acknowledgments
The fruitful journey of my Doctor of Nursing program (DNP) was made possible by the unconditional support of extraordinary and cherished individuals, such as Dr. Khoa and Don Nguyen, MD, for serving as my preceptor/mentor throughout the stages of my direct immersion project. Dr. Dawn Robinson, my Faculty /Chair, for her unshaken patience, quick feedback, and radiant positive energy, together with Dr. Katherine McDermott and faculty in course level review, reading countless revisions and providing knowledgeably expert guidance to the end of this course.
To my colleagues, Jeffrey Souza, Tresa Antony, Mercy Daniel, Lisa Johnson, Marissa Rafael, and Skyler Meyer, thank you for your unfading support. Countless times, I felt like the world has collapsed upon me, desperately seeking the way out in the darkness, lo and behold, your torchlights point through the doors of escape. I recognized each day we journeyed that the race was worth it because you all were there pointing your lights to the proper outlet.
To my supportive friends, Sr. Onyinyechukwu Uba, Ms. Euphemia, Ms. Amaka, Dr. Bashiru, Calista, Sylvia, Vincent, and Ogunbayode. Thank you for your support, encouragement, love, and understanding, especially in moments of desolation, sequestration, and poor communication from me due to loads of assignments on my table.
To my preceptees, Vivian, Michael, Adaeze, Jane, Kate, Esther, Marybeth, Florence, Ebong, Nkele, and others, your understanding when I transfer my frustrations to you humbled me most in my relationship with you as a preceptor. Looking upon the “role model thing” was the driving force that propelled me to this finishing point. You are more than welcome anytime for more guidance in the future in your further studies.
I was also working on my post-graduate certification program in the psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner program, and this is where I thank Dr. Ghislaine Mogo, my preceptor, for her tremendous patience and support.
To my spiritual family, the Daughters of Charity of the Most Precious Blood, God gave me the best opportunity to be among you. Mother Ofelia Marzocca, see what I have become this day because of your decisions in the most challenging moments of my life and humble expression of an arduous journey that would benefit all. Thank you all, and may God reward us according to our deeds.
Table of Contents
Statement of the Problem vii
Chapter1:IntroductiontotheProject 1
BackgroundoftheProject 2
ProblemStatement 3
PurposeoftheProject 4
ClinicalQuestion 6
AdvancingScientificKnowledge 7
SignificanceoftheProject 9
RationalefortheMethodology 11
NatureoftheProjectDesign 11
DefinitionofTerms 13
Assumptions,Limitations,Delimitations 15
SummaryandOrganizationoftheRemainderoftheProject 17
Chapter2:LiteratureReview 19
TheoreticalFoundations 22
ReviewoftheLiterature 25
PrevalenceofHypertension 26
AerobicExerciseHealthIntervention 32
EffectofExerciseonBloodPressure 34
Summary 39
Chapter3:Methodology 40
StatementoftheProblem 41
ClinicalQuestion 42
ProjectMethodology 44
ProjectDesign 44
PopulationandSampleSelection 46
InstrumentationandSourcesofData 48
Validity 49
Reliability 49
DataCollectionProcedures 50
DataAnalysisProcedures 52
PotentialBiasandMitigation 53
EthicalConsiderations 53
Limitations 54
Summary 55
Chapter4:DataAnalysisandResults 57
Chapter 4 summarizes the collected data and how it was analyzed. Other chapter segments include the problem statement, clinical question, and methodology. The results are presented in narrative form along with figures, tables. The last section of the chapter provided a preview of Chapter 5 and its contents. 58
Descriptive Data 58
Data Analysis Procedures 59
Results 60
Chapter5:Summary,Conclusions,andRecommendations 64
At the clinical site, the project manager, Medical Director, and clinic manager collaborated regarding the increased ambulatory blood pressures noted within the past three months. The standard of care at the site is through medication management for their condition. Hence, a unanimous decision was made to utilize a new strategy, implementing the American Heart Association’s guidelines on aerobic exercise to influence hypertensive patients. 64
Chapter 5 reintroduced the project’s topic and summarized the project. Other chapter segments included a summary of the project’s findings and conclusion, theoretical, practical, and future implications. The last portion of the chapter offered recommendations for future quality improvement projects and clinical practices. 64
Summary of theProject 65
Thisquality improvement project was conducted utilizing a quantitative methodology and quasi-experimental design in four weeks. Chapter 1 presented studies such as Adam and Wright (2020), Aung and Htay (2021), Krist et al. (2021), and Saco-Ledo et al. (2020) related to incorporating aerobic exercise to be included in an individual’s HTN management plan.The project contributed to the current body of literature, such as Aung and Htay (2021), Krist et al. (2021), and Saco-Ledo et al. (2020), regarding aerobic exercise being included in hypertension management. The impacted population was adults diagnosed with hypertension in a primary care clinic. The county’s demographics revealed that roughly 60,000 seniors 65 and older comprise the county’s populace (Data USA, 2019). In Texas, the incidence of HTN is at 35.1%, which validates findings from the CDC (2021) and Million Hearts (2021). 65
Chapter 2 discussed Orem’s self-care deficit theory and Lewin’s change model are the theoretical underpinnings for this quality improvement project. Orem’s self-care theory was chosen because it focused on the reciprocal relationship between humans and their environment (Orem, 1995). The theory highlighted that a human could provide self-care, and the primary goal of the healthcare provider should assist them in achieving an optimal level of independence (Orem, 1995). The nursing theory comprises five constructs: universal self-care requisites, normalcy, developmental self-care requisites, and health deviation self-care requisite (Orem, 1995). Implementing this theory permitted the project manager to guide the clinicians regarding their responsibilities in providing the patient with a transparent plan of care. This helped the HTN patients to sustain an appropriate level of self-care (Orem, 1995). 65
Lewin’s change model was selected for this quality improvement project. It was chosen because it emphasized the need for change for clinicians and HTN patients impacted by restraining forces (Lewin, 1947). The change model consists of three phases: unfreezing, change (movement), and refreezing (Lewin, 1947). The first phase, unfreezing, began when the project manager collaborated with the nursing manager, medical director, and a few nursing staff to detect the increase in ambulatory blood pressures in HTN patients within the past three months. The second phase, changing (movement), began when the project manager educated the staff to use the implementation of the American Heart Association (AHA) guidelines related to aerobic exercise. During the phase, the patients were educated by the staff, clinicians were trained, and the project was monitored. The last stage, refreezing, began when the discussion about the AHA guidelines became infused into the organizational culture and a daily habit in the healthcare providers’ clinical practice (Lewin, 1947). 66
The project was implemented once approval was received from Grand Canyon University IRB and the project site. It was implemented in four weeks to examine the impact of AHA guidelines related to aerobic exercise on ambulatory blood pressures. The project came after collaboration with the medical director and some nursing staff showed an increase of 37.1% in diagnosed HTN patients within the past six months. The project contributed to the current body of literature regarding the impact of aerobic exercise on decreasing one’s hypertension (Aung &Htay, 2021; Krist et al., 2021; Saco-Ledo et al., 2020). Other areas affected by regular aerobic exercise are weight loss, improved well-being, and decreased symptoms of depression and anxiety (CDC, 2022). 66
SummaryofFindingsandConclusion 67
Implications 69
The nursing field is a discipline that requires research, which concentrates on issues that affect the nursing practice (Polit & Beck, 2021). Nursing implications are essential in considering when to begin a new medication, intervention, or procedure (Polit & Beck, 2021). Healthcare providers who understand the potential impact they could have on the clinical practice, nursing care, and the patient allows them to provide the best quality care (Polit & Beck, 2021). The implications discussed in the following sections were developed on the project findings. 69
Theoretical Implications 69
PracticalImplications 71
The third implication is for clinicians to use an interactive pictorial wheel to improve self-management in HTN patients. This educational style using pictures can help patients discuss their personalized approach to managing HTN without feeling belittled or embarrassed. Furthermore, this method has been adapted for other diseases such as asthma, heart failure, and stroke (Gan et al., 2022). This communication style would be beneficial for individuals with low health literacy levels. The communication wheel would be based on medication, exercise, weight management, diet, and complications 72
Future Implications 72
Recommendations 72
Recommendations for Future Projects 73
The “next step” in forwarding this project is for the healthcare providers to deliver patient care using culturally competent care for this populace. Unfortunately, many of the patients seen at the clinic are from Black and Brown communities. As mentioned in Chapter 1, the project site’s demographics show a high population of Hispanics (36.72%) and Blacks (18.5%). This confirms the statistics found by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2022), Hispanics (39%), and Blacks (56%). 73
RecommendationsforPractice 74
References 76
AppendixA 90
GrandCanyonUniversityInstitutionalReviewBoardOutcomeDeterminationLetter 90
AppendixB 91
AmericanHeartAssociationPhysicalActivityGuidelines 91
AppendixC 92
Permission to Use the American Heart Association Physical Activity Guidelines 92
List of Tables
Table1.DescriptiveDataforAge
58
Table2.DescriptiveDataforGenderandRace
59
Table3.Paired
t
-TestResultsforSystolicBloodPressureLevels
60
Table4.Paired
t
-TestResultsforDiastolicBloodPressureLevels
61
Chapter1:IntroductiontotheProject
Hypertension(HTN)isamedicalconditionassociatedwithhigherbloodpressure,wherebythearteriesthattransportbloodbecomedamaged.Despitetheavailabilityoftreatmentstrategies,lessthanoneinfiveindividualshavetheirbloodpressureundercontrol(Ghatageetal.,2021).Currently,intheUnitedStates(U.S.),thediseaseposesasignificantproblemthataffectsoverhalfoftheadultpopulation(37millionindividuals)(CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention[CDC],2021;Kristetal.,2021).Complicationsoftheconditionincludemyocardialinfarction,heartfailure,chronicrenaldisease,andstroke(Ghatageetal.,2021).
TheincreaseinthecasesofhypertensionpromptedtheAmericanHeartAssociationTaskForce(AHA)topublishnewguidelinestohelpmanagetheriseinhypertensionamongAmericanadults(Wangetal.,2019).OnecriticalchangewithintheAHAguidelineistheimprovisedreferenceanddefinitionofhypertensionvalues.TheAmericanCollegeofCardiologyandtheAmericanHeartAssociationguidelinesforhypertensionmanagementanddefinitionofHTNdefinesitashavingbloodpressureatorabove130/80mmHg(TheAmericanCollegeofCardiology(2022);AmericanHeartAssociation,2022).Atthesametime,stage2HTNisbloodpressureatorabove140/90mmHg(CDC.,2021).Improvedbloodpressure(BP)amonghypertensivepatientshasbeenassociatedwithpositivehealthoutcomes(Severinetal.,2020),andearlydetectionandcontrolofBPhavesignificantlyimpactedmorbidityandmortalityratesinthehealthcaredeliverysystem(CDC,2021;Severinetal.,2020).
Attheprojectsite,theprojectmanagercollaboratedwiththeMedicalDirectorandclinicalmanagerregardingtheincreasingambulatorybloodpressuresseenwithinthepastthreemonths.Althoughthesiteprovidepatientswithmedicationmanagementfortheirdisease,itwassuggestedthatanotherstrategybeemployedtohelpreducebloodpressure.TheconversationconcludedwiththeprojectmanagerimplementingtheAmericanHeartAssociation’sguidelinesonaerobicexercisetoinfluencehypertensivepatients.
The project was worth conducting because it helped toincreaseHTNpatients’knowledgelevelsandassistinhelpingthemchangetheirbehaviorstocombatthis“silentkiller”(CDC,2019).Unfortunately,manyindividualsareunawareofthesymptoms,whichmakesthesituationdire.Thisprojectpromotedecreasingthefifthleadingcauseofdeath(CDC,2019).Otherareastheprojectimpactsone’simprovementoftheirqualityoflife,reducingtheirchancesofstroke,protectingtheirkidneys,anddecreasinghealthcarecosts(CDC,2019).
Chapter1introducesthetopicofhypertensionandtheuseofdailyphysicalactivitytocombatthedisease.Othersectionsofthechapterincludetheproblemstatement,purposestatement,andclinicalquestion.Otherareasofthechapterinvolveadvancingscientificknowledgerelatedtothetheoreticalunderpinnings,quantitativemethodology,andquasi-experimentaldesign.Thechapter’slastsegmentscomprisethedefinitionofterms,assumptions,limitations,anddelimitationswithapreviewofChapter2.
Background of the Project
TheprevalenceofhypertensionamongtheadultpopulationintheUnitedStatesincreasedrapidlybetween1988to2010,accountingforhalfofallfatalitiesfromstroke,end-stagerenaldisease(ESRD),andstroke(MillionHearts,2021).AccordingtoMuntneretal.(2020)trendanalysis,theestimatedproportionoftheU.S.adultpopulationsufferingfromhypertensionbetween1999and2000was31.8%.Theadultpopulationaffectedbyhypertensionincreasedfrom31.8%in1999-2000to48.5%in2007and2008(Muntneretal.,2020).ThenumberofaffectedU.S.adultshasbeenontheriseeversince,andbetween2013and2014,whichwas53.8%(Muntneretal.,2020).Thepercentagedroppedslightlyfrom53.8%to43.7%between2017and2018,butthevalueisstillrelativelyhigh(Muntneretal.,2020).ThisdataimplythattheAmericanpopulationisconsiderablyaffectedbyhypertensionatanalarmingrate.
Thecurrenthypertensivepopulationimpactedbyambulatorybloodpressureis43.7%,accordingtoarecentstudybyAdamsandWright(2020).Currently,atthefacility,therearenostandardizedguidelinesforeducatinghypertensivepatientsregardingincorporatingexercise(dailyphysicalactivity)asabloodpressuremanagementmechanism.Thestandardtreatmentsincludemedicationssuchasdiuretics,angiotensin-convertingenzyme(ACE)inhibitors,angiotensinIIreceptorblockers(ARBs),andcalciumchannelblockers(MayoClinic,2021).Aftercollaboratingwiththemedicaldirectorandnursingstaff,thedecisionwastoimplementtheAHArecommendationforaerobicexercisetohelplowerambulatorybloodpressureamongthisclinic’sadulthypertensivepopulation.
Problem Statement
ItwasnotknownifortowhatdegreetheimplementationoftheAmericanHeartAssociation’sguidelineonaerobicexercisewouldimpactambulatory bloodpressurewhencomparedtocurrentpracticeamongadulthypertensivepatients.Attheclinicalsite,therearenostandardizedguidelinesforclinicianstoeducatehypertensivepatientsregardingimplementingdailyphysicalactivityasabloodpressuremanagementmechanism.Collaborationwiththemedicaldirectorandsomeofthenursingstaffshowedanincreaseof37.1%indiagnosedHTNpatientswithinthepastsixmonths.Theclinic’sfindingscorrespondedwiththehealthstatisticsfromtheTexasDepartmentofStateHealthServices(2022),asthecountyranks22intheStateswithdiagnosedhypertensivepatients.Thedata,incombinationwithcurrentliteraturebytheCentersforDiseasePreventionandControl[CDC](2021),emphasizesthathypertensionaffectsapproximately45%ofAmericanadults.
Theprojectcontributestothecurrentbodyofliterature,suchasAungandHtay(2021),Kristetal.(2021),andSaco-Ledoetal.(2020),regardingaerobicexercisebeingincludedinhypertensionmanagement.TheCDC(2020)statesthatregularphysicalactivityisessentialforgeneralwellness,weightloss,andwell-being.Otherareasimpactedarethereducedsymptomsofdepressionandanxiety(CDC,2020).Theprojectvalidatesthatusingaerobicexercise,asstatedbySaco-Ledoetal.(2020),decreasesone’ssystolicbloodpressurebyapproximately2to4mmHginnormotensiveand5to8mmHginhypertensionadultpatients.
Purpose of the Project
The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the implementation of the American Heart Association’s guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four week-period.TheindependentvariablefortheprojectistheAmericanHeartAssociation’s guidelines,andthedependentvariableisbloodpressuremeasurements.Conveniencesamplingwillbeusedtochoosetheparticipants.Theprojectwas conductedwithinfourweeksusingaquasi-experimentaldesignandquantitativemethodology.SixhealthcareproviderswillbeeducatedusingtheAmericanHeartAssociation’sguidelinesforaerobicexercise(walking and blood pressure measurement using Oscar 2 Device) for HTN patients. The primary investigation carried out implementation and comparison of data during the project using ambulatory blood pressure baseline and post-implementation data.Datawasretrievedfromtheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecordandinputintoaMicrosoftExcelspreadsheet.An outside statistician not associated with the primary investigator or project analyzed the data.Apairedsamplet-testwasusedtoanalyzethestatisticalsignificanceofthevariablesusingtheStatisticalPackagefortheSocialSciences(SPSS-28).
Theinclusioncriteriafortheparticipantswere18andolder,diagnosedwithHTN,currentclinicpatients,andabletoparticipateinaerobicactivity.Theexclusioncriteriaarepatientswithmusculoskeletaldisabilities,mentaldisorders,andindividualswithcomorbiditiesthatcouldbiastheprojectfindings.Theparticipantsengagedinaerobicexercisefor30minutesin24hours,threedaysaweek,forthefourweeksoftheproject duration. The outcome post-intervention was a reduction in ambulatory bloodpressurereadingoftherecommendedBPbelow140/80mmHg.TheaveragedecreaseinSBPwithaerobicexerciseisapproximately2to4mmHginnormotensivepatientsand5to8mmHginadulthypertensionpatients(Saco-Ledoetal.,2020).
Thepersonswhoimplementedtheinterventionwereonephysician,twonursepractitioners,tworegisterednurses,andonemedicalassistant.Allhealthcareproviderswereeducatedregarding“theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelinetoincludeexerciseinHTNpatients’diseasemanagement.The use of Oscar2 Device for measuring ambulatory blood pressure. The clinicians demonstrated vibrant understandingviatheteach-backmethodtotheprojectmanagertosafeguardalltheparticipantswere taughtthesameway.Theindividualscurrentlyworkfulltimeattheclinicforoveroneyearandhaveaccesstothedocumentationsoftware.
Theprojectsite’sgeographiclocationisinsouthwestTexas,themostpopulouscountyandthethirdmostpopulouscountyintheUnitedStates(U.S.CensusBureau,2020).TheaffectedpopulationwaspatientsdiagnosedwithHTN.ThedemographicsshowadiversepopulationofWhite(28.9%),White-Hispanic(36.72%),Blacks(18.5%),Asians(6.9%),andLatinos(8.98.%)(U.S.CensusBureau,2020).Manyresidentsovertheageof60havechronicdiseasessuchas(chronicobstructivepulmonarydisease,heartdisease,anddiabetes)(UTHealthScienceCenteratHouston,2020).Theagegroupsinthecounty18to34(20,586),35to54(46,513),and55to64reflecttheparticipantsintheproject.
Theprojectcontributestothenursingfieldbyofferinganevidence-basedstrategyandevaluatinghowaerobicexercisessuchaswalkingimprovedambulatorybloodpressure.Theprojectprovidedvitalinformationthatcouldbesharedwithothernursingstafforhealthcareprovidersatotherprimarycareclinics,minoritycommunities,orpopulationsinsimilardiversepopulations.The project also preferred an avenue for helping individuals and families to understand the relationship between the disease process and its management.
Clinical Question
Saco-Ledoetal.(2020)conductedasystematicreviewandmeta-analysis.Theauthorsclaimedthatambulatorybloodpressure(ABP)betterpredictscardiovasculardiseaseandmortalityinadulthypertensivepopulations.Aerobicexerciseplayedasignificantroleinloweringbloodpressure,anditwasbeneficialinloweringambulatorybloodpressureinHTNpatients.Thefollowingclinicalquestionthatguidedthisquantitativeproject:Towhatdegreedidtheimplementationof“theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineonaerobicexerciseimpactambulatory bloodpressurewhencomparedtocurrentpracticeamongadulthypertensivepatientsinaprimarycareclinicinsouthwestTexas? Theindependentvariableis“theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineregardingaerobicexercise,andthedependentvariableisambulatory blood pressure.
Advancing Scientific Knowledge
ImplementinganaerobicexerciseeducationprogramtolowerambulatorybloodpressurebyfollowingAHAguidelines,theinitiativeimprovedpopulationhealthoutcomesforhypertensiveindividuals.Completingthisqualityimprovementprojectadvancedourunderstandingofambulatorybloodpressureinhypertensivepatientstoreduceormanageambulatorybloodpressure.Theoverallgoalsofaerobicexercisewalkingincontrollingbloodpressureinhypertensivepatientsweretodecreasemorbidityandincreasethepopulation’swellness, happiness and vitality.Physicalactivitiessuchaswalking,running,swimming,andbikingimprovesymptoms,qualityoflife,functionalstatus,andreduceshospitalizations(CDC,2021).
Inclinicalpractice,managementofcardiovasculardiseasesentailedresolvingcardiovascularetiologiessuchascoronaryheartdiseaseandrelatedconditionssuchasdiabetes,preventativecare,follow-upmonitoringofcardiacstatus,carecoordinationandcasemanagement,educatingandsupportingpatientsforself-management,rehabilitationofheartfunction,andhealthpromotion,amongothers(Jiang&Wang,2021).Thepharmacologicaltreatmentofcardiovasculardiseaseshasimprovedwiththedevelopmentofnewtherapiesandunderstandingitspathophysiology.DespitedevelopingnovelpharmacologicalinterventionsforpatientswithHTN,congestiveheartfailureexistingtreatmentshavenotyieldedsignificantmortalitybenefitsforHFpatientswithheartfailurewithreducedejectionfraction(HFpEF).Instead,thedrugtreatmentstrytocontrolsymptoms,treatcomorbidities,andriskfactorsthatthecausethroughmeasuressuchasaerobicexercise,dietandweightcontrol,bloodpressureself-monitoring,andlowsodiumintake,amongothers(CDC,2021).
Theidentifiedgapistheelevatedambulatorybloodpressureamongthehypertensivegroupbasedontheavailableresearch(Blumenthaletal.,2018;Saco-Ledoetal.,2020).Educationalprogramsonaerobicexercisetodecreaseandmanageambulatorybloodpressureshouldbuildonthefindings(Blumenthaletal.,2018).Otherfactorsthatinfluencebloodpressurearethepresenceofcomorbiditiesandriskybehaviorssuchassmoking,patients’educationlevel,caregiverpresence,andin-patientHTNeducation.As the patients became more aware of the aerobic exercise in lowering blood pressure through the educational program, individuals showed less comorbidities that reduced risk to hypertensive complications and frequent hospitalizations (Saco-Ledo, 2020). TheinitiativefilledthegaporneedbyutilizingtheAHAguidelinesforaerobicexerciseeducationprogramstolowerambulatorybloodpressureforpatientswithhypertension.
TheselectedtheoreticalframeworkforthisqualityimprovementprojectwasDorothyOrem’sself-caredeficittheory.Basedonthetheory,patientsmustengageinself-caretomaintainandimprovetheirqualityofhealth(Orem,1995).Utilizingthistheory,thenursesdidnotseetheirpatientsasinactiveorreceivinghealthservices;instead,theyconsiderthemstrongandreliabletoparticipateindailyactivitiesanddecision-makingprocesses(Orem,1995).ThreenursingsystemsaredefinedinOrem’snursingtheory;theyincludewhollycompensatory,partiallycompensatory,andsupportive-educativestrategies(Khademianetal.,2020).Forthisproject,thefocusisonthelastsystem(supportiveeducationalsystem).Thecliniciansassessedthepatient’sreadinesstolearnsomethingnewbutneedassistanceandguidance.Patientswithchronicillnessesrequiremotivationandtheskillstoconductthebehaviorsneededtomaintainandimprovetheirhealth(Khademianetal.,2020).Hence, the patient gained the capability to learn disease processes and perform activities independently, overcoming seen and unseen limitations.
Lewin’schangemodelwaschosentoworkincombinationwithOrem’sself-caredeficittheory.Itwasselectedbecauseitwasawaytodescribetheprocesschangeversusguidingtheactivitiesthatwere conducted.ThetheoryworkedwellwithOrem’snursingtheoryinimprovingthepatient’sself-efficacyandmanagementofhypertension.Furthermore,thismodelallowedtheprojectmanagertoactivelyexaminetheclinicsiteandclinicians’changeprocessandprogression(Harrisonetal.,2021).Themodelconsistedofthreestages:unfreezing,changing(movement),andrefreezing(Lewin,1947).Thefirststage,unfreezing,allowedtheprojectmanager,medicaldirector,andafewnursingstaffmemberstoidentifytheproblem,developanevidence-basedstrategy,andconsenttochange(Lewin,1947).Thesecondstage,movement,happenedwhentheinterventionwasimplemented.Thehealthcareprovidersprovidedatimelinewithaclearplanthat were followed for the project(Lewin,1947).The last stage, refreezing, occurred whentheinterventionbecameadailyparttheclinicalpracticeandconversationwithhypertensivepatients(Lewin,1947).
Significance of the Project
The significance of the quality improvement project wasimplementingarecommendedevidencebasedstrategyby“theAHA’sguideline”regardingaerobicexercise.ImplementingtheprojecthelpeddecreasethehealthcarecostsassociatedwithHTNintheUnitedStates.Commodore-Mensahetal.(2018)statethatthefinancialpricesaresignificant,approximately$131-198billionannually.Hypertensivepersonsincuranextra$2,000yearlyinhealthcareexpenditurescomparedtonon-hypertensivepersons(Commodore-Mensahetal.,2018).Furthermore,HTNisacrucialriskfactorinvariousdiseases,includingmyocardialinfarction,heartfailure,stroke,andchronicrenaldisease(Commodore-Mensahetal.,2018).
OnenursingimplicationrelatestoLewin’schangemodelincreatingandsustainingchange.Amulti-systematicapproachmustbe drawnfromthemodeltosupporttheimplementationoftheAmericanHeartAssociationguidelinesregardingaerobicexerciseforhypertensivepatients.Themodelhighlightedtheprinciplesrelatingtopeoplechangingfromtheonset,discussingtheirfeelingsregardingthechange,andsupportingtheprocessviacommunicationandcollaboration(Harrisonetal.,2021).
The second nursing implication relates to the participants’ management of their disease process (hypertension). The participants were taught the importance of including aerobic exercise and walking (30 minutes, three times a week) in their private daily schedules.Theprojectmanagerevaluatedtherespondents’understandingandreceptivenesstonewinformationandsafetymeasuresrelatedtoexercising.
Rationale for the Methodology
Thequantitativemethodologywasusedtoprovideinformationthatusesnumericaldata(StatisticalSolutions,2019).Thismethodbestansweredtheclinicalquestionandaddressingtheproblemstatementforthisprojectbecauseitallowedanin-depthcomparisonoftherelationshipbetweenpre- andpost-interventionresults(Guetterman&Fetters,2018).Itwasusedbecauseitofferedobjective,systematic,andfocuseddataanalysisstrategies(Guetterman&Fetters,2018).Inthisproject,theprojectmanagerevaluated“theAHA’sguidelines”anditsimpactonthebloodpressureofHTNpatients.Thedependentvariableweremeasuredfourweeksbeforeandafterimproving theintervention.Thismethodologywasthemostappropriatebecauseotherinvestigatorscouldreplicatethedata(Creswell&Creswell,2018).
Aqualitativemethodologywasconsideredbutdeemedinappropriateforthisproject.Itfocusedondescribingthecharacteristicsorqualitiesofaphenomenon(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thismethodisoftenthematicandsubjective,andfindingsareproducedusingtheparticipants’wordsverbatim(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Inthisproject,theprojectmanagerdidnotseektounderstandtheparticipants’behaviors,feelings,orlivedexperiences(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thedatawasanalyzedusingacodingmethodthatexploresthemesandpatterns(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Theresultswerepresentedverbatimintwotothreecolumnsusingtherespondent’swords.
Nature of the Project Design
Aquasi-experimentaldesignwasusedinthisqualityimprovementproject.Therationalebehindselectingtheproject,asmentionedabove,wasthatitallowedforcomparingthedependent(bloodpressure)andindependentvariables(implementationstrategyaerobicexerciseeducationguideline.Thedesignwassuitableforscrutinizingtheproject’svariablesanddeterminingtheindependentvariable’seffectonthedependentvariable(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Furthermore,thedesigndidnotallowtheparticipantstoberandomlyassigned(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Forthisproject,thedependentvariable(ambulatory bloodpressure)weremeasuredattwodifferenttimes(oncebeforetheinterventionandonceaftertheintervention(Creswell&Creswell,2018).
Acorrelationaldesignwasnotselectedforthisqualityimprovementproject.Itwasnotchosenbecauseitisanon-experimentaldesignwherethevariablesaremeasuredandevaluatedfortheirrelationship(correlation)(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thevariablescannotbecontrolled(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Tworationalesfor notusingthistypeofdesignareevaluatingthecausalstatisticalrelationshipsbetweenthevariablesandnotmanipulatingtheindependentvariable(Creswell&Creswell,2018).
The project sample exploredwasadultpatientsdiagnosedwithHTN.Theindividualswere18orolder,spokeEnglish,andwereabletoparticipateinaerobicexercise.Theexclusioncriteriaincluderespondentswithmentalchallenges,musculoskeletaldisabilities,andcomorbiditiesthatcouldbiastheprojectresults.ThesamplesizewascalculatedusingG*Powersoftware,version3.1.9.2,withanalphameasureof0.05,aneffectsizeof0.5,andapowerof80%.TheminimumnumberofparticipantssuggestedfortheprojectwasN=34.
The data collection process was began after receiving theapprovaltoconducttheprojectfromGrandCanyonUniversityInstitutionalReviewBoardandtheclinicalsite.ThedatacollectionproceduresincludededucatingthesixhealthcareprovidersforonehourusingtheAHAguideline(aerobicexercise)andslidepresentation.Theclinicians demonstratedtheproceduresviatheteach-backmethods.Allpotentialparticipantswereeducatedregardingtheminimalrisksandbenefitsofpartakingintheproject.Thedemographicdatawas retrievedfromtheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecords(age,gender,race,maritalstatus,andeducation).
Definition of Terms
Aqualityimprovementprojectmustofferthereaderanunderstandingoftheterms,concepts,andvariablesused(GrandCanyonUniversity,2021).Newknowledgeiscriticaltosuccessfulsolutions(Polit&Beck,2018).Beloware the words used intermittently throughout the project
Ambulatory Blood Pressure Monitoring(ABPM)
Ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringwasintroducedintheearly1960sandwas usedtoassessone’sbloodpressureinreal-time(Shackelford,2022).Ahealthcareprovidertypically evaluatedthebloodpressureduringroutineactivitiessuchasworking,sleeping,ordoingchores(Shackelford,2022).
The American College of Cardiology Foundation
The American College of Cardiology Foundationisanon-profitmedicalorganizationdedicatedtoimprovingthelivesofcardiovascularpatients(AmericanCollegeofCardiology,2022).Thiswasdoneviacontinuousqualityimprovementmonitoring,patient-carestrategies,paymentinnovation,andprofessionalism(AmericanCollegeofCardiology,2022).
American Heart Association
TheAmericanHeartAssociationwasformedin1924toestablishscientificresearchthatcouldofferhealthcareprovidersandpatientsmethodstotreatcardiacdiseaseandprevention(AmericanHeartAssociation,2022).
Aerobic Exercise
Aerobicexercisereferstoanyactivityinvolvingcardiovascularconditioningandpertainstorunning,briskwalking,swimming,orevencycling.Thisprojectwillapplyaerobicexercisetohelphypertensivepatientsreducetheirambulatorybloodpressure(Sealsetal.,2019).
Highbloodpressurereferstothescenarioinwhichanadult’sbloodpressureisabovetheoptimumlevel,whichisusuallyat130/80mmHgforadultpatients.Whenapatient’sbloodpressureexceedstheoptimumshownabove,theyareexposedtotheriskofchronicheartfailure,stroke,myocardialinfarction,andinextremecircumstances,death(Fuchs&Whelton,2020).
Hypertensive Patients
Hypertensivepatientsreferstothepatientsdiagnosedwithhypertensionsincehypertensionhasbeenshowntobeacausativefactorforotherdiseasessuchaschronicheartfailure,stroke,andevenmyocardialinfarction(Schwingshackletal.,2019).
Assumptions, Limitations, Delimitations
GrandCanyonUniversity(2021)statedthatanassumptionisanindisputablefact.ThefirstassumptionwasthatthisqualityimprovementprojectwasbasedontheAHAguidelineonaerobicexerciseeducationprogramwillenhancetheself-efficacyofadulthypertensivepatientsbyhelpingthemkeeptheirbloodpressureatoptimumlevels.Inturn,theAHAguidelineontheaerobicexerciseeducationprograminterventionwouldplayapivotalroleinlifestyleimprovementandskilldevelopmentwhichwere requiredtoencourageimprovedhealthoutcomesandadaptivehealth-relatedbehavior(Cameronetal.,2018).Thesecondassumptionwasthatallparticipants answeredthequestionshonestly.Tomaintainhonestyfromtheparticipantsduringtheproject,theprojectmanagerdidnotinfluencetheparticipantsanswers.Tomaintainobjectivityandreducethepossibilityofthedatabeingskewed,theinvestigator hiredanoutsidestatisticiantoconductthedataanalysis(StatisticalSolutions,2019).
Thethirdassumptionwasthattherespondentswereengagedandinterestedinparticipatinginthisqualityimprovementproject.Theunderlyingpresumptionwasthatpeoplewereresistanttochange.Toimprovetheparticipants’engagementintheproject,theprojectmanager allowedanopportunityforfeedbackregardingthedatacollectionprocess.AggarwalandRanganathan(2019)emphasizethatcollectingpertinentdatathatcanbereproducedcaninformandcollaboratewiththestaffonevidence-basedstrategiesrelatedtohypertensioncare.
Limitationsaresituationstheprojectmanagercannotcontrol(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thefirstlimitationwastherestrictedtimetoconducttheproject(fourweeks).Alongitudinalprojectallowsonetoevaluatethetrendsandchangesovertime(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Secondly,itreviewsthechronologicalsequencingofevents,acriticalcriterionforestablishingcausality(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).
The second limitation was the small sample size. This would have reducedtheprojectfindingsandincreasethemarginoferror,renderingtheresultslimited (Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Theprimaryproblemwithasmallsamplesizewasinterpretingtheresults,mainlyrelatedtotheconfidenceintervalsandp-values(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Largersamplesizesproducenarrowerconfidenceintervals(CI),hence,preciseprojectresults(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Thesecondproblemwithasmallsamplewasthattheycouldproducefalse-positiveresultsorover-evaluatethemagnitudeofanassociation(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).
The third limitation was the data analysis. Data were collectedfromthefacility’selectronicrecordandinputintoaMicrosoftExcelspreadsheet(codebook).Ifthedatawasnotinsertedcorrectly,theresultsmayresultinfalseormisleadinginformation(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Duetotheprojectmanager’slimitedknowledgeandtimeinconductingstatisticalanalysis,anoutsidestatisticiannotaffiliatedwiththeprojectormanager performed the data analysis.
Delimitationsaresituationsthattheprojectmanagercancontrol(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thefirstdelimitationwastheselectedclinicalsite.Itwaschosenbecauseitwasaccessibleandconvenientfortheprojectmanagerrelatedtotheparticipants.Theseconddelimitationwastheinclusioncriteriaforparticipatingintheproject.Thethirddelimitationwastheselectedtopicbecausetheprojectmanagerwasinterestedinhypertensionandaerobicexerciseinmanagingthedisease.
Summary and Organization of the Remainder of the Project
According to Saco-Ledoetal. (2020), adult hypertension cases were soseverethattheyresultedin$370billioninannualdirectmedicalcostsworldwide.Kristetal.(2021)alsoprovidedaninclinatoryhypothesisthatfullysupportsSaco-Ledoetal.(2020)findingsbynotingthat45%ofAmericanadultssufferedfromhypertension.IntheadultpopulationofAmerica,hypertensionincreasedsteadilybutquicklybetween1988and1994,1999and2000,and2009and2010.AccordingtoresearchbyWangetal.(2019),therewasasharpincreaseinoccurrencesofhypertension.
TheAmericanCollegeofCardiology(ACC)disclosedthatphysicalexerciseeducationandparticipationshouldbeseenasawayofimprovinghealth,modifyinglifestyle,andmaintainingbloodpressureasessentialtopreventinghypertension(ACC,2022).Whiletheconditionwasserious,itwasprimarilyattributedtootherchronicconditionssuchasstroke,end-stagerenaldisease(ESRD),anddeathinextremeinstances.AsaffirmedbyMuntneretal.(2020),between1999and2000,theratewas31.8%,whichfastroseto48.5%between2007and2008.Between2013and2014,theratesrapidlyroseto53.8%(Muntneretal.,2020).
Orem’sself-caredeficittheoryandLewin’schangemodelwerediscussed.Orem’sself-caredeficittheoryguidedcliniciansinrealizingthattheirpatientsare activeparticipantswhocanparticipateindailyactivitiesthatbenefittheirhealthandintheclinicaldecision-makingprocess(Orem,1995).Lewin’schangemodelprovidedanoverviewofhowachangeprocesscould beimplementedandsustainedusingthethreephases(unfreezing,movement,andrefreezing)(Lewin,1947).
Theproject’ssignificancewaslargelyattributedtoimplementing“theAHA’sguideline”aerobicexerciseeducationprograminterventionhelpedhypertensivepatientsmanagetheirbloodpressure.Theprojectfitswithinandcontributedtothecurrentliteratureortheclinicalsitepracticebyhelpingbridgetheexistinggap(Aung&Htay,2021;Kristetal.,2021).Thequantitativemethodologywas used as it effectivelyportrayedobservedoutcomesandinterventionsfromthequalityimprovementproject.Aquasi-experimentaldesignwasusedsinceitallowedforthecomparisonofthepre-andpost-interventionmeasures.Apairedsample
t-testwasusedtodeterminethestatisticalsignificanceofthevariables.
Chapter2 reviewedthepreviousandcurrentliteratureontheeffectivenessofaerobicexerciseonAmbulatoryBloodPressure(ABP)amonghypertensivepatients.Thechapterdiscussedthetheoreticalunderpinningsusedintheproject(Orem’sself-caredeficittheoryandLewin’schangemodel).Theprimarythemesweretheprevalenceofhypertension,aerobicexercise,andinterventiontocontrolhypertension.Thesubthemeswillbespecifictothethemesrelatedtohypertensionandaerobicexercise.ThelastsegmentofthechapterofferedapreviewofChapter3anditscontents.
Chapter2: Literature Review
Highbloodpressure,alsoknownashypertension(HTN),isaleadingriskfactorforglobalcardiacdisease(Hoffmannetal.,2020).LowadherencetoHTNtreatmentamonghypertensivepatientsremainsahealthcarechallenge(Hoffmannetal.,2020).Schwingshackletal.(2019)statethathypertensionisaconditioninwhichthepatientsinvolvedhavehighbloodpressureexceedingthesetoptimalBP(140/90mmHg).However,whenapatient’sbloodpressureexceeds180/120mmHg,thentheirconditioncanbetermedassevereandwouldbeexposedtootherchronicconditionssuchasheartdiseaseswhicharearesultofthelong-termforcecausedbythebloodpressureonarterialwalls(Schwingshackletal.,2019).
Increasingclinicians’awarenessofthevariousstrategiesinHTNmanagementandincludingthepatientsintheshareddecision-makingcouldimprovetheirqualityoflife.OnemethodthatcanbeusedinimplementingtheAmericanHeartAssociationguidelineregardingaerobicexercise.Attheprojectsite,therewerenostandardizedguidelinesforeducatinghypertensivepatientsregardingincorporatingexercise(dailyphysicalactivity)asabloodpressuremanagementmechanism.The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the implementation “the American Heart Association’s” guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks.
Chapter2exploredpreviousandcurrentliteratureregardingambulatorybloodpressureandaerobicexercisebeingincludedinthedailymanagementofhypertension.Orem’sself-caredeficittheoryandLewin’schangemodelwerediscussedindetail.Threeprimarythemesforthetopicofhypertensionaretheprevalenceofhypertension,aerobicexercise,andtheeffectsofexerciseonbloodpressure.Thesubthemesfortheprevalenceofhypertensionincludedsystolicbloodpressuremanagement,diastolicbloodpressuremanagement,anddiastolicbloodpressuremanagement.Thesubthemesforaerobicexercisearepre-aerobicexercisestate,duringaerobicexercise,state,andpost-aerobicexercisestate.Thefinalsubthemesfortheeffectsofexerciseonbloodpressureconsistofliteracylevel,self-efficacy,andlifestylemodification.ThelastfewsentencesofthechapterprovidedapreviewofChapter3.
A literature search was conducted using peer reviewedarticlesfrom2018tocurrent.ThekeywordsandinclusioncriteriaincludedwritteninEnglish,hypertensionadults,aerobicexercise,AmericanHeartAssociationguideline,DorothyOrem’sself-caredeficittheory,hypertension,hypertension-relatedconditions,andLewin’schangemodel.Theexclusioncriteriawerenon-Englisharticlesandpediatrics.ThefollowingdatabaseswereusedduringthereviewCINAHL,CochraneLibrary,EMBASE,GoogleScholar,GrandCanyonUniversityonline,andPubMed.Over374.070resultswerediscovered;however,anexclusionfilterwasused,andthequantitywasreducedto19,431results(Adams&Wright,2020).articleswereusedforthisreview.However,50articleswereusedthatmettheinclusioncriteria.
Ahistoricaloverviewshows1988to2010;hypertensionwasattributedto50%ofdeathswhichwereanextensionoftheirhypertensivenaturethroughend-stagerenaldisease(ESRD)andstroke(Wangetal.,2019).AnotherreportbyMuntneretal.(2020)showsthatthepopulationofpatientsdiagnosedwithhypertensionroseby31.8%between1999and2000.Intheprecedingyears,between2007and2008,therateroseto48.5%(Muntneretal.,2020).Themostrecentonewasin2018,whentherateswereat43.7%,aslightdropfromtheinitial48.5%.Theratesmighthavedroppedslightly;however,therateof43.7%isstillrelativelyhigh,whichcallsfortheadoptionofalternativeinterventionsthatwouldhelpexpeditethedropintherateofthepopulationaffectedbyhypertension.
Saco-Ledoetal.(2020),affirmsthathypertensionisacriticalconditionandiscurrentlytheleadingcauseofprematureglobaldeaths.TheAmericanHeartAssociationsetthenewhypertensiondiagnosisthresholdinthesystematicreviewasaBP≥130/80mmHg(Asayamaetal.,2019).However,theEuropeanSocietyofHypertension(ESH)maintainsthathypertensionisbestdefinedusingathreshold≥140/90mmHg(Saco-Ledoetal.,2020).
Apatientisexposedtootherco-morbiditieswhentheirconditionisnotmaintained.Thisendangerstheirliveswhichcallsforanevidence-basedinterventionthatcanbestbesuitedtohelpingsuchpatientscopewiththeconditioninquestion.Thepatient’ssystolicanddiastolicBPmustbemaintainedattheoptimumlevel,failuretowhichaninterventionwouldhavetobesoughttohelpreducethemtobewithintheoptimalrange.AspertheAHAguidelines,anelevatedBPhasasystolicBP≥140mmHgordiastolicBP≥90mmHg(Saco-Ledo, et al, 2020) However,theinitialclassificationundertakenbytheAHAwas130/80mmHg(Asayamaetal.,2019).
Utilizingapracticalinterventionthatwouldhelpalleviatetheeffectsofhypertensionismainlyattributedtotheknowledgeofthelong-termimpactthattheconditionhasonthepatientinquestion.Whenpatientsareawareofthelong-termeffectsofhypertensionontheirqualityoflife(QoL),theywillbemotivatedtodoastheirdoctorsaysortake medicationsthatthedoctorprescribes.However,inthecaseofthisqualityimprovementproject,theprimaryinvestigator(PI)proposesusing“theAHA’sguideline”foraerobicexerciseeducationprogramtohelpkeeptheBPatoptimallevelsamonghypertensivepatientsinsoutheastTexas.
Oneofthemostproblematicissuesregardingusing“theAHA’sguideline”foraerobicexerciseeducationprogramwaswhethertheusewouldbeinstrumentalinhelpingpatientswithambulatorybloodpressurereducethem.BurnierandEgan(2019)assertthatresearchhasestablishedtherelationshipbetweenhypertensionandcardiovasculardisease.Theauthorsreinforcedtheinherentneedtoascertainthatpatientsstrugglingwithhypertensionarewithintheirmeanstomaintaintheirbloodpressure.
Theoretical Foundations
Thetheoreticalframeworkremainedoneoftheessentialelementsinresearchandqualityimprovementstudies.Itformsthefoundationonwhichallknowledgeintheprojectisunderpinned,servingasthesupportandstructurefortheprojectsrationale,problemstatement,significance,purpose,andresearchquestions(Kivunja,2018).AccordingtoSaco‐Ledoetal.(2020),highbloodpressureisthecauseofmanycasesofhighmortalityratesandcardiovasculardiseasesamongtheadultpopulationintheUnitedStates(U.S.).Therefore,itfittedtopostulatethathypertensionisasignificanthealthcrisisintheU.S.andneedsmoreattention(CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,2021).
Orem’sself-caredeficittheoryandLewin’schangemodelarethetheoreticalunderpinningsforthisqualityimprovementproject.Orem’sself-caretheorywasselectedbecauseitemphasizesthemutualrelationshipbetweenhumanbeingsandtheirenvironment(Orem,1995).Thetheoryemphasizesthatallhumansarecapableofself-careandtheprimarygoaloftheclinicianwastohelpthemobtainanoptimumlevelofindependencewiththeirdiseaseprocess(hypertension)(Orem,1995).Itconsistsoffiveareasofself-carerequisites:universalself-carerequisites,normalcy,developmentalself-carerequisites,andhealthdeviationself-carerequisite(Fotokianetal.,2021).Utilizingthistheoryallowedtheprojectmanagertoexplaintothehealthcareproviderstheirrolesandresponsibilitieswhileofferingthepatientaclearoutlineofthecareplan.Inturn,thishelpedhypertensivepatientstoachieveandmaintainasuitablelevelofself-care(Orem,1995).
Khademianetal.(2020)conductedaquantitative,quasi-experimentalstudytoevaluateaself-careeducationalprogramdevelopedandbasedonOrem’snursingtheory.EightyIranianhypertensivepatientsparticipatedinthestudy.Datawascollectedpre-and-posteightweeksofinterventionusingthe
QualityofLifeofCardiacPatientsand
StrategiesUsedbyPeopletoPromoteHealthsurveys(Khademianetal.,2020).Datawereanalyzedusingchi-square,independent
t-test,andAnalysisofVariances(ANOVA)withrepeatedmeasures(Khademianetal.,2020).TheresultsshowedthatthemeanscoreoftheQualityofLifeintheexperimentalgroupwashigherthanthecontrolgrouppost-eight-weekintervention(106.5±26.5vs.85.5±22.5,
p=0.03)(Khademianetal.,2020).Themeanscoresofself-efficacieswerenotstatisticallydifferentfromthoseofthecontrolgroupimmediatelyafter(68.5±12.7vs.66.5±12.2,
p=0.47)andeightweeksaftertheintervention(70.5±13.5vs.65.7±12.0,
p=0.10)(Khademianetal.,2020).TheauthorsconcludedthatusingandeducatinghypertensivepatientswithOrem’snursingtheoryasaguidecouldimprovetheirqualityoflife(Khademianetal.,2020).
Lewin’schangemodelwasselectedforthisproject.Themodelproposesthathypertensivepatientsandcliniciansareinfluencedbyrestrainingforces(Lewin,1947).Thesebarrierscounter-driveforcesthatkeptthepositiveforcesforchangepushedinthedirectionthatwillcausechangetooccur(Lewin,1947).Thetensionbetweenthedrivingandrestrainingforcesmaintainsequilibrium(Lewin,1947).Themodelconsistsofthreeconstructs:unfreezing,changing(movement),andrefreezing(Lewin,1947).
Thefirststage,unfreezing,occurredwhentheprojectmanagercollaboratedwiththemedicaldirector,nursemanager,andsomenursingstaffinidentifyingtheincreaseinambulatorybloodpressuresinhypertensivepatientsoverthepastthreemonths.Thesecondstage,changing,allowedthecollaborationteamtoseekalternativestrategiesinhelpingthispopulaceachieveanoptimallifestyle(Lewin,1947).Hence,theimplementationoftheAHAguidelinesrelatedtoincludingaerobicexercisewasintroduced.Duringthisphase,educatingthepatients,trainingtheclinicians,andmonitoringtheprojectoccurred.Thelaststage,refreezing,integratedthenewstrategyintheorganization’sculture,sothatitbecameahabitinthedailyclinicalpracticeandminimized resistance to change (Lewin,1947).
AquantitativestudyconductedbyHenryetal.(2021)evaluatedhowtoimprovepatientsafetybyimplementingareferralprocessfromtheemergencydepartmenttoreducetheriskoflosstofollow-up.Theauthorsfocusedonpatientswithseizure-relatedorsuspectedepileptic,cardiogenic,oracutesymptomatic(Henryetal.,2021).TheauthorsselectedLewin’schangemodeltoguidetheinteractiontoimplementtheproject.Theresultsshowedthatthemedianwaitingtimepre-implementationwas65.0days(range37daysto163days),andthemedianwaitingtimepost-interventionwas31.0days(rangeeightdaysto175days)(t30.9=9.42;p<0.001).Processmeasuresweremetwith100%compliance(Henryetal.,2021).TheprojectconcludedwiththeemergencydepartmentmakingsignificantimprovementsusingLewin’schangemodeltomanageseizurepatients.Themodelwasessentialformanagingalargehealthcareorganizationwithmultiplestakeholders(Henryetal.,2021).
Smith(2018)conductedaquantitativeprojecttodeterminethecorrelationbetweenbloodpressure(meanarterialpressures)andimplementing30minutesofaerobicexercisethreetimesaweekfor30minutesin30hypertensiveadults.Lewin’schangemodelwasutilizedforeducatingtheoutpatientparticipants(Smith,2018).Theprojectexpectedthattheparticipantswouldlearnaboutthebenefitsofaerobicexerciseandengageinanewbehavior(walking)(Smith,2018).Theauthorstatedtherationaleforusingthechangemodelwastousetheeducationtounfreezetheparticipants’currentbehavior,movingstage(engageinwalking),andrefreezing(adoptingwalkingaspartoftheirlifestyles(Lewin,1947;Smith,2018).Theresultsshowedthatafterfourweeks,eightparticipantshadengagedinregularaerobicexercise,threetimesaweek(Smith,2018).Althoughtheresultswerenotstatisticallysignificant,theprojectshowedhowtheuseofLewin’schangemodelenhancedandguidedtheeducationprocessfortheparticipants.
Review of the Literature
Thisliteraturereviewofferedanevaluationofevidence-basedstudiesthatvalidatedtheproject’ssubjectmatter.Theprimarythemesandsubthemesarerestrictedtohypertension,ambulatorybloodpressure,andaerobicexercise.Theprimarythemesarepreventionofhypertension,aerobicexercise,andeffectsofexerciseonbloodpressureThesubthemesforpreventionofhypertensionincludesystolicbloodpressuremanagement,diastolicbloodpressuremanagement,andambulatorybloodpressuremanagement.Thesecondsetofsubthemesareaerobicexercisearepre-aerobicexercisestate,duringaerobicexercisestate,andpostaerobicexercisestate.Thelastsubthemesofeffectsofexerciseonbloodpressureincludeliteracylevel,self-efficacy,andlifestylemodifications.
Prevalence of Hypertension
Hypertensionistheresultofone’sbloodpressurebeingtoohigh.CDC(2021)disclosedthatabouthalfofadults(45%)withuncontrolledhypertensionhaveabloodpressureof140/90mmHgorhigher.Thisincludes37millionU.S.adults(Cameronetal.,2018).Itisnotnewsthatsomepatientsdonotgivethemselvestheappropriatehealthcaretheydeserve.SomeHTNpatientsdonotknowtheirbloodpressure(BP)baseline,makingithardtodetectornoticetheincreaseordecreaseintheirBPreadings.Kirklandetal.(2018)opinedthattheestimatedprevalencerateofadultsdiagnosedwithHTNwouldincreasebyapproximatelyninepercentfrom2010to2030;anincreaseinuncontrolledBP-associatedcomplicationswillbecomeasignificanthealthissueamongAmericancitizens(Cameronetal.,2018).
TheWorldHealthOrganization[WHO](2021)statedthatabout1.28billionadultsaged30to70yearsworldwidehaveHTN,andlessthanhalfofadultsdiagnosedwithHTNaretreated(Cameronetal.,2018).Themodifiableriskfactorsincludechangingunhealthyhealthhabitssuchassmoking,inactivity,alcohol/tobaccoconsumption,beingoverweightorobese,andexcesssaltintake;thenon-modifiableareage>65years,coexistingdiseasessuchasdiabetesandfamilyhistory(CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,2021).ManagementofHTNinvolvesdecreasedsaltintaketolessthan5gdaily,improvedphysicalexercise,reducedalcohol,andtobaccouse,weightmanagement,andincreasedconsumptionoffruitsandvegetables(CDC,2021;Wheltonetal.,2017).
TheWHOestimatesthatmorethan1.28billionpeopleaged30to79yearsworldwidesufferfromhypertension.Two-thirdsofthesepeoplearefromlow-incomeandmiddle-classhouseholds(CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,2019).Furthermore,46%ofadultswithhypertensionareunawarethattheysufferfromthecondition.Therefore,lessthanhalfofadultswithhypertensionarediagnosedandtreated(CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention,2019).Thenumberofhypertensionpatientswiththehealthconditionundercontrolisalsolow.Itisestimatedthatoneinfiveadultswithhypertensionhasthediseaseundercontrol(Carey&Forsyth,2022).Hypertensionisamongtheleadingcausesofprematuredeathintheworld.Asaresult,itisamongthenon-communicablediseaseswithhealthcaretargetstoreduceitsprevalence.Thegoalistoreducehypertensionprevalenceby33%between2010and2030(Fuchs&Whelton,2020).
IntheUnitedStates(U.S.),hypertensionprevalenceisalarming.HypertensionputsAmericansatahigherriskofheartdiseaseandstrokes.ThesetwoaretheleadingcausesofdeathintheUnitedStates.In2020alone,morethan670,000deathsbecauseofdiabeteswerereportedinAmerica(Fuchs&Whelton,2020).WithnearlyhalfofAmericanadultsintheUnitedStateshavinghypertension,onlyoneinfourpatientshavetheconditionundercontrol(Guirguis-Blakeetal.,2021).HypertensionprevalenceintheUnitedStatesvarieswithgenderandrace.Hypertensioniscommonlynotedinmen,with50%ofmeninAmericahavingthiscondition,while44%ofhypertensionpatientsinAmericaarewomen(Fuchs&Whelton,2020).Furthermore,hypertensionismoreprevalentamongblackAmericanadultsat56%,whiteAmericanadultsat48%,Asianadultsat46%,andHispanicadultsat39%(Guirguis-Blakeetal.,2021).HighbloodpressureisalsocommoninsomeareasoftheU.S.comparedtoothercountries.
MeasurementofSystolicBloodPressureManagement.TheWHO(2021)describedHTNasamedicalconditiondiagnosedwhenbloodpressureismeasuredontwodifferentdays;thesystolicbloodpressurereadingsonbothdaysare≥140mmHg,andthediastolicbloodpressurereadingsonbothdaysare≥90mmHg(Krameretal.,2019).ThefirstofthetwonumbersusedinbloodpressureisknownastheSBP,whichdemonstratesthearterialpressurewhentheheartcontracts(WHO,2021).Primaryhealthclinicsarebetterpositionedtoeducatepatientsonissuesconcerningtheirhealth,treatmentoptions,andpatient-centeredself-management(Yatimetal.,2019).Whenthesystolicbloodpressuremeasurementsareabove140whilethediastolicbloodpressurereadingonapatientisunder90,theconditionisreferredtoassystolichypertension(Krameretal.,2019).Systolichypertensionisseenmoreamongolderadults.
DiastolicBloodPressureManagement(DBP).
TheDBPisthesecondnumberreadingheardthatrepresentsthepressureinthevesselswhentheheartrestsbetweenbeats(Saco-Ledoetal.,2020;WHO,2021).Diastolicbloodpressureisexperiencedwhenthereadingsareconsistentlyover90(Krameretal.,2019). A higher risk of cardiovascular disease and stroke is associated with every 10 mmHg over a diastolic blood pressure reading of 40 to 89. The significance of DBP is therefore emphasized (Saco-Ledo et al., 2020). A patient’s DBP results may indicate an urgent clinical necessity to lessen potential hazards and illnesses. Filling up the knowledge gap requires educating the public on the significance and ramifications of different blood pressure measurements.
AmbulatoryBloodPressureManagement(ABPM)
.
Ambulatorybloodpressuremanagementisaneffectivewayofmonitoringandmanaginghypertensivepatients.Thebloodpressuremeasurementsaretakenover24hours,whetherthepatientisawakeorasleep(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).ItwasintroducedasamethodallowingthecollectionofBPvaluesnumeroustimesanhourover24hours.Forexample,thereadingscanbetakenover20and30-minuteintervalsthroughoutthedayandnight(Mandinietal.,2018).Furthermore,heartratereadingscanbeaddedforenhancedABPM.Afterthat,thereadingsareaveragedforeachday,andchangesinbloodpressurearecalculated.
Additionally,statisticssuchaschangesinheartrateandbloodpressuredistributionpatternsarecalculated.BPmeasureshavelongbeenrecognizedascriticaltoolsfordoctorsindetectingandmanaginghypertension(Asayamaetal.,2019).Incorrectapplication,lackofuniformity,orpatientorfamilyerrorsafterreceivinginstructionswerealleliminatedbytheABPM,whichwasconsideredaccurate.ToevaluatethemeanSBPorDBPrecordedreadings,itwasnecessarytoconsiderABPM’smultiplereadings.AccordingtotheAHAguidelines,Diastolicandsystolicbloodpressurelevelsshouldbelessthan125and75millimetersofmercury,respectively(Mandinietal.,2018).OneoftheadvantagesoftheABPMwasthatitwasmoreaccuratethanaone-timemeasurement(Dadlanietal.,2018).ItispossiblethattheABPMcoulddetectvariationsincircadianrhythms,suchassleep-wakecyclesandbloodpressurefluctuations,inresponsetoenvironmentalandemotionaldisturbances(Dadlanietal.,2018).
Patientswerereluctanttowearthecufffor24hoursbecauseofthediscomfortitcausedandthefactthatittriggeredevery30minutesatnight,makingambulatorybloodpressurecontrol(ABPM)ineffective(González-dePazetal.,2019).Dadlanietal.(2018)alsonotedpractitioners’lackofavailability,understanding,andvaryingawarenessofambulatorymonitoring.Therefore,itispossiblethatusingABPMmadeitmorechallengingtogetanaccuratebloodpressurereadingwhileexercising.
Ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringprovidedenhancedinformationonhowbloodpressurechangeswithaperson’sdailyactivitiesandsleep.ThismonitoringstyleisrecommendedbytheAmericanHeartAssociationandtheAmericanCollegeofCardiologyasthesuitablemodeforbloodpressuremanagement Mostpeoplerecordadecreaseofaround20%insystolicbloodpressurewhenasleep(MillionHearts,2021).However,someexperiencezerodropsduringsleep (Saco-Ledo, et al., 2020). Inuniqueinstances,somepeoplerecordedariseinsystolicbloodpressureduringsleep. (Million Hearts, 2021).Ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringisadvantageousbecauseitcandetectbloodpressurechangesthatmightgounnoticedwithotherbloodpressuremanagementtechnology.
Ambulatorybloodpressuremanagementcandetectwhite-coathypertension,maskedhypertension,andsustainedhypertension(Rêgoetal.,2019).Whitecoathypertensioniswitnessedwhenhypertensivepatientswhodon’ttakehypertensivedrugsrecordhighbloodpressurereadings.Thisphenomenoncanleadtothemisclassificationofhypertensivepatientswithnormalbloodpressure.Tentothirty percentofpatientswithhighbloodpressurereadingshaveexperiencedwhitecoathypertensionathealthcarefacilities(Rêgoetal.,2019).GuidelinesinABPMprohibittreatmentwhenbloodpressurereadingsarewithinthenormalrangeoutsidethedoctor’soffice(StatisticalSolutions.,2019).However,itisuptothehealthcareproviderandthepatienttomonitorthebloodpressurereadingsforearlydetection.Ontheotherhand,maskedhypertensionoccurswhenthebloodpressurereadingsareexpectedwhenthepatientisatthedoctor’sofficebutriseswhenthepatientisathome (Rêgo etal., 2019) Maskedhypertensionoccursinmorethan20%ofpeoplewithuntreatedhypertension(Rêgoetal.,2019).
Furthermore,maskedhypertensioncarriesthesameriskassustainedhypertensionandshouldbemanagedwithhypertensionmedications.Lastly,sustainedhypertensionoccurswhenthehighbloodpressurereadingishighatthedoctor’sofficeandathome.Sustainedhypertensionincreasestheoccurrencesofheartandkidneyproblems.Aidingdetectionandmanagementofhypertension,ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringwasusedtodeterminetheefficacyofvariousantihypertensivemedicationsusedtocontrolhypertension(Rêgoetal.,2019).Bymonitoringbloodpressurereadingsthroughoutthedayandnight,healthcareproviderscandetermineiftheprescribedhypertensivedrugshaveeffectivelycontrolledhighbloodpressure.Asaresult,ahealthcareprovidercanmakepatientdecisionssuchasincreasingthedosageorusingadditionalmedicationstomanagebloodpressure.Additionally,ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringaidsinthepredictionofthelikelihoodofheartdiseases.Sincehypertensionislinkedtoheartdiseasesandorgandamage,datafromambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringcanbeusedforthepredictiveanalysisofsuchoutcomes(Miaoetal.,2020).
Aerobic Exercis
e Health Intervention
AccordingtoSealsetal.(2019),aerobicexerciseisanyactivityinvolvingcardiovascularconditioningandpertainstorunning,briskwalking,swimming,orevencycling.TheAHAguidelinefocusedonwalking;howmuchexercisewegetdailydependsonhowmuchweknowaboutexercise.Thevariables,includingaerobicexerciseandbloodpressurereadings,was usedasthekeyindicatorsintheanalysissoftware.Saco-Ledoetal.(2020)conductedasystematicreviewandmeta-analysis.Theauthorsclaimedthatambulatorybloodpressure(ABP)isabetterpredictorofcardiovasculardiseaseandmortalityinadulthypertensivepopulations.Thestudiesusedincluded910participantsdiagnosedwithhypertensionandwereexposedtoaerobicexercisesforeightto24weeks,spreadoutthroughouttheweeksasthreetofivesessionseachweek.Within24hoursofbeingsubjectedtoaerobicexercises,thereweresignificantreductionsinparticipants’DBPandSBP{diastolicBP,−3.0mmHg[−5.4to−0.6],systolicBP,−5.4mmHg;[95%CI,−9.2to−1.6]}TheassessmentoftheDBPandSBPwasdoneusingarandom-effectsmodel,whichposednoconflicts.Exercisehadasubstantialimpactonloweringbloodpressurethroughouttheday,includingduringthedaytime(systolicBP,4.5mmHg;[95percentCI,6.6to2.3];diastolicBP,3.2mmHg[4.8to1.5]),evening(systolicBP,4.7mmHg[8.4to1.0];diastolicBP.Allthemeasuresusedonthepatientssubjectedtoaerobicexercisesyieldedsignificantbenefits(p<0.05).Thecurrentresearchreviewdemonstratesthemeasurabledecreasedoutcomeofexerciseonbloodpressurereadings(Saco-Ledoetal.,2020).
Theauthorsproposedwalkingwithanotheraerobicexerciseforpeoplewithhighbloodpressuretobringitdown(Mandinietal.,2018).Physicalactivityhasbeenemphasizedasanessentialcomponentinmanagingcardiovasculardiseases.Studiesinvolvingparticipantswhopracticedmoderatetointensiveexercisesfoundthattheseparticipantsexperiencedalowincidenceofcardiovasculardiseases.Theseparticipantsexperiencedoverallimprovedhealthoutcomes.Additionally,large-scalepopulationstudiesshowthatparticipantswitha15-minutedailyexerciseroutineexperienceareductioninmortalityduetocardiovascularissuesby15%(Muntneretal.,2020).Therefore,physicalactivityhasphysiologicaleffectsonparticipants’cardiovascularsystems.Theseactivitiesimprovevascularendothelialfunctionandenhancedvasodilationduringbloodflow(Viranietal.,2020).
Additionally,physicalactivityreducestherestingheartrateduetoamechanismthatincreasesparasympathetictone(Wheltonetal.,2017).Astudyfoundthataerobicsexercisesandphysicalactivitiesincreasevasculogenicbyusingendothelialprogenitorcells(Severinetal.,2020).Lastly,physicalactivityhasbeenknowntoincreaseaperson’stoleranceforischemiaandreperfusioninjury.AstudyconductedinChinafoundthatthecardiovasculardiseasemortalityratehasincreasedsignificantlybymorethan50%from1990to2009(Sealsetal.,2019).TheincreaseinthecardiovasculardiseasemortalityrateinChinawasattributedtothelackofphysicalactivityamongitscitizens.Suchstudiesindicatethatphysicalactivityplayedacrucialroleinthereductionofcardiovasculardiseaseincidences,whoseriskfactorwasthepresenceofhighbloodpressure(Wangetal.,2019).Therefore,itwasvitaltoperformresearchstudiesevaluatingaerobicexercise’seffectonbloodpressuremanagement.
Aerobicexercisesincreasebreathing,oxygenation,andheartrateduringtheperformanceofaerobicactivities.Asaresult,aerobicexerciseskeeptheheart,lungs,andcirculatorysystemhealthy(Shackelford,2022).Researchdatacreditaerobicexercisesforimprovingcardiovascularhealthandloweringbloodpressure.Additionally,aerobicsexerciseshavebeenlinkedtoregulatingbloodsugar,improvingsleep,andboostingaperson’smood.Anadditionaloutcomeofregularaerobicsexercisesisweightmanagement(Shackelford,2022).
AerobicexerciseshavebeenrecommendedthroughoutEuropeandAmericaaspartoftheguidelinestoreducehypertensionprevalence.Itwascitedthatmoderate-intensityaerobicexerciseseffectivelyreducebloodpressurereadingsinhypertensivepatients(Ansteyetal.,2021).Furthermore,theseexercisescanlowersystolicanddiastolicbloodpressureinhypertensivepatientsofallgenders(Ansteyetal.,2021).Theexercisesareeffectivelyattributedtoreducingbloodpressurelevelsforhypertensivepatientsineitherstageoneorpre-hypertension.However,existingstudiesreportthatexercisetrainingdisruptsthecirculatorysystem(Chobufoetal.,2020).Theresearchshowedthatexercisedisruptsthebalancebetweenvasodilationandvasoconstriction.Thisresearchcitedthatexercisealtersvasodilationandvasoconstriction-relatedcytokinessuchasnitricacid.Thesestudiesconcludedthatnoevidencesupportsthehypothesisthatexercisereducesbloodpressureinhypertensivepatients.
Furthermore,researchontrimesterexercisetrainingshowsnoreductionintheparticipants’bloodpressure.Theexceptiontotheresearchontrimesterexerciseisparticipantswithresistancehypertension(Fordeetal.,2020).Therefore,thisprojectwascrucialindeterminingthedegreetowhichaerobicexerciseswouldimpactbloodpressuremanagementinhypertensivepatients.
Effect of Exercise on Blood Pressure
In2018,thepercentageofU.S.adultsaged18andoverwhometthe2008federalphysicalactivityguidelinesforaerobicactivitywas53.3%(95%confidenceinterval=52.25%-54.27%)whichwasnotsignificantlydifferentfromthe2017estimateof53.1%(Sakhujaetal.,2022).TheAmericanHeartAssociation(AHA)developedandreleasedaprogramin2019called”ExerciseWithinReach”forthepublictouse.Thisapplicationusedmaterialalreadyinthepublicdomainanddidnotrequirepermissiontobeused.Walkingaerobicexercisewaswhatthestudy’sauthorsproposeforpeoplewhohavehighbloodpressuretobringitdown(Mandinietal.,2018).
Regularphysicalexercisehasbeencitedtoreducebloodpressureinhypertensivepatients.Asaresult,physicalexercisehasbeenwidelyrecommendedaspartofthehypertensionguidelinesintheUnitedStates.Hypertensivepatientsareencouragedtoparticipateinaerobicexercisesdaily.Aerobicexercisesvary.Theexercisescaneitherbeintheformofwalking,jogging,orswimming.Thehypertensionguidelinesrecommendoneoftheseexercisesatleastthirtytofortyminutesdaily(Shimboetal.,2020).Innormotensives,regularphysicalexerciseshavebeenrecordedtohavereducedtheaveragesystolicbloodpressurelevelsbybetween3to5mmhg(Vaughanetal.,2022).Ontheotherhand,thediastolicbloodpressurereductioninnormotensivesbecausephysicalexerciseaveragesbetween2to3mmhg(WorldHealthOrganization,2021).Inhypertensive,thedegreetowhichbloodpressurehasbeenrecordedtohavereducedbecauseofphysicalexerciseinmorethaninnormotensives.
However,thereislimitedresearchontheeffectsofexerciseonresistanthypertension.Resistanthypertensionisregisteredwhenthereisafailurebythebloodpressuretoberegulateddespiteusingthreeormoreantihypertensiveagents,includingadiuretic.Therefore,resistanthypertensionisresistanttodrugtherapy.However,itremainsunclearwhethertheresistanceofresistanthypertensiontodrugtherapyappliestootheralternativemechanisms,suchasaerobicsexercises.Additionally,theprevalenceofresistanthypertensionischallengingtoverify.
Inastudytotestthehypothesisthatanaerobicexerciseprogramcanreducebloodpressure,researchersconductedarandomizedcontroltrial(Williamsonetal.,2022).Fiftysubjectsparticipatedinthetrialsbycarryingouttreadmillexercisesfor8to12weeks.Bloodpressurewasmonitoreddayandnightinadditiontopulsewaveanalysis.Resultsshowedthatthetreadmillexercisessignificantlydecreasedtheparticipants’systolicanddiastolicbloodpressure.Furthermore,increasedphysicalperformanceresultedinunchangedarterialcomplianceandcardiacindex.Therefore,theseresultsshowthatphysicalexercisesdecreasebloodpressureinhypertensivepatientsandshouldbeusedtomanageresistanthypertension.
Saco-Ledoetal.(2020)conductedasystematicreviewofthestudyinvolvingadultsinthreegroups.Thefirstgrouphadparticipantswithnormalbloodpressure.Thesecondgroupcontainedparticipantswithprehypertensionsymptoms.Thelastgroupcontainedparticipantswithhypertension.Theresultsfromthisstudyindicatedthatphysicalexercisecausedareductioninthebloodpressurelevelsinparticipantswithhighbloodpressureandapre-hypertensivestate.
LiteracyLevel.
Healthliteracydeterminestheexchangeofcomplexinformationamongpatientsandhealthcareproviders.Lowlevelsofhealthliteracyarestandardinhealthcare.Asaresult,healthcareilliteracyaffectsmanagingconditionssuchashypertension(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Thefactorswereattributedtolowhealthliteracy,suchasculturalbackground,lackofeducationalresourcesandfinances,dietaryhabits,lifestyle,andlackofawarenessoraccesstohealthcare(Schillinger,2020).Educationenablespatientsandeveryotherindividualthestrengthtounderstandtheirhealthconditions,manage,andseektreatment.
Additionally,lowliteracylevelswerecommonamonghypertensivepatients.Inastudyconductedtodeterminethecorrelationbetweenhealthliteracyandhealthoutcomesinhypertensivepatients,itwasdeterminedthatpatientswithlowliteracylevelsarelikelytohavelimitedknowledgeandunderstandingregardingHTNself-management(Nerenbergetal.,2018).However,thestudywasinconclusiveindeterminingwhetherthelimitedknowledgepossessedbyhypertensivepatientswithlowliteracylevelclinicaloutcomesofbloodpressuremanagement.
Ithasbeendemonstratedthatmaintainingahealthylevelofphysicalactivitycanreduceone’sbloodpressure(BP)(Mandinietal.,2018).Patientswithchronicdiseasesoftenfinditchallengingtomanagetheirhealthconditions;theywillrequireextendedsupporttoattainaqualityoflifebymonitoringtheirBP,medicationcomplaints,decreasingexacerbationswithmorbidandhospitalizations(Carey&Forsyth,2022;Yatimetal.,2019).Itisapredictingfactorintreatmentadherenceforhypertensivepatients.
Self-Efficacy.
Inastudytoexaminetheroleofself-efficacyinmanaginghypertension,atotalof1087participantsintwogroupswereusedtoconductthisresearch(Beaneyetal.,2019).Onegroupcontainedparticipantswithhypertension,whiletheothergroupcontainedpatientswhodidnotdevelophypertension.Thetwogroupswereexaminedusingfivefactorstoassesspatientmanagementwithchronicconditions.Thedomainsincludedailyactivities,emotions,medication,andtreatment.
Thetwoadditionalfactorsusedforthestudyweresocialinteractionsandsymptoms.Thisstudyshowedtheparticipantswithhypertensionreportedchallengesinmanagingday-to-dayactivitiescomparedtothecontrolgroup(Lurbeetal.,2016).Furthermore,participantswithhypertensionshowedthatself-efficacyinfluencesthegeneralqualityoflifeforhypertensivepatients.Theseresultsshowedthatself-efficacypredictshypertensivepatients’physicalandmentalhealth.
LifestyleModification
.
Wheltonetal.(2017),intheirstudyonchronicdiseaseself-managementutilizingtheHypertensiveSelf-ManagementEducationProtocol,disclosedthatApproachestoStopHTN(DASH),dietarysodiumrestriction,activeparticipationinphysicalactivity,moderationofalcoholconsumption,cessationofsmoking,andadherencetomedicationregimestocontrolBP(Schillinger,2020).Self-medicationhasbeentestedtohaveimprovedinreducingPBthroughmedicationadherence,exercise,dietmodification,andweightdecrease(MillionHearts,2021).Lifestylemodificationshavebeencitedashavingadirectimpactonhypertensionmanagement.TheAmericanSocietyofHypertensionoutlinesthehypertensionclinicalguidelines.Theclinicalguidelinesrecommendincorporatingaerobicexercisesandreducingsaltintake.Additionally,theclinicalguidelinesrecommendnoalcoholandsmokingtoreducetheriskofhypertension.Healthydietsforoverweightorobesepeoplehavealsobeenrecommended.
Furthermore,theDietaryApproachestoStopHypertension(DASH)hasbeenwidelyrecommendedforbloodpressuremanagement.TheDASHdietishighinfruitsandvegetables.Itemphasizesincorporatingwholegrains,whitemeat,andlow-fatdairyproducts.Additionally,thedietislowinfat,redmeat,andprocessedfoodssuchassugarydrinksandrefinedcarbohydrates.TheDASHdietaimstoreduceweightandheartrateandlowertheriskofdiabetes.Arecentstudyfoundthatreplacingcarbohydrateintakewithproteinreducedbloodpressureinhypertensivepatients(MillionHearts,2021).Therefore,theriskofcardiovasculardiseaseswasreducedsignificantly.
In the Saco-Ledo (2020) trial, 910 individuals who had been diagnosed with hypertension had aerobic exercise exposure for 8 to 24 weeks, spaced out as 3-5 sessions per week. Within 24 hours of participating in aerobic activity, participants’ DBP and SBP (diastolic BP, 3.0 mm Hg [5.4 to 0.6], systolic BP, 5.4 mm Hg; [95% CI, 9.2 to 1.6]) significantly decreased. A random-effects model was used to evaluate the DBP and SBP, which created no conflicts of interest. Blood pressure was significantly lowered by exercise
Summary
NewhypertensiondiagnosticcriteriaissuedbytheAmericanHeartAssociation(AHA)callforabloodpressurereadingof130/80millimetersofmercury(mmHg).AccordingtotheEuropeanSocietyofHypertension,140/90mmHgistheoptimumthresholdfordefininghypertension.Saco-Ledoetal.(2020)suggestedthathypertensivepatientsshouldbeeducatedontheAHArecommendationaerobicexerciseprogramtomaintainoptimalbloodpressurelevels.
Chapter2discussesLewin’schangemodelandOrem’sself-caredeficittheory.Threesignificantconceptswereexaminedindepthwithinthechapter.First,basedonthetheoreticalfoundations,itwasexpectedthattheAHAguidelinesonaerobicexercisewouldsignificantlyimpactambulatorybloodpressurewhentheyareputintopractice.Patientsareencouragedtofeelthattheirhealthcanberestoredorevenenhancedbeforeahealthdiagnosis,whichisthecoreprincipleoftheidea.
Participantsmustaltertheirwayoflifetobeself-efficaciousthroughOrem’sself-caretheoryeffective.Aspartoftheproject’sgoals,smokersanddrinkersdiagnosedwithhypertensioncanstopengagingintheseunhealthyhabits.Threemajorthemeswereexaminedindepthinthischapter.Thefirstwastheprevalenceofhypertension.Thefirstthemeontheprevalenceofhypertensionhasthreesub-themesrelatedtomeasuringtechniquesforhighbloodpressure.Thesub-themesincludesystolicbloodpressuremanagement,diastolicbloodpressuremanagement,andambulatorybloodpressuremonitoring.Themetwowasaerobicsexciseimpactonbloodpressure.Thisthemewassubdividedintothreesub-themes:pre-aerobicexercise,duringaerobicexercise,andpost-aerobicexercisestates.Thethirdthemeistheeffectoftheexercisestate.Thisthemewasdividedintosub-themesthatinfluencetheeffectofexerciseonbloodpressuremanagement.Thesub-themesincludehealthliteracy,self-efficacy,andlifestylechanges.
Chapter3presentstheproject’smethodology,problem,andpurposestatements.Othersegmentsofthechapterincludetheproject’sclinicalquestion,projectdesign,population,andsampleselection.Thechapterexaminestheproject’sdatasources,validityandreliability,datacollectionandanalysisprocedures,andethicalconsiderations,followedbyprojectlimitations.
DuetothegrowingprevalenceofhypertensionintheAmericanadultpopulation,thisprojectfocusedonimplementingAHAguidelinesonaerobicexercises.PhysicalinactivityhasbeenidentifiedasoneofthecriticalfactorsassociatedwiththedevelopmentofHTN;hence,numerousguidelinesrecommendincreasingtheuptakeofphysicalexercisesasaprotectivefactoragainstHTN(Commodore-Mensahetal.,2018).Oneevidence-basedstrategythatcanbeusedtocombatHTNisimplementingAHAguidelinesregardingaerobicexercise.Severalstudies,suchasSaco-Ledoetal.(2020)andSeverinetal.(2020),emphasizetheimportanceofphysicalactivityandthatitcanhelpreduceHTN.The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the implementation “the American Heart Association’s” guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks.Theindependentvariableisthe“AmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineregardingaerobicexercise,andthedependentvariableisbloodpressures.
Thisprojectwasimplementedinfourweeksutilizingaquasi-experimentaldesignandquantitativemethodology.Currently,attheprojectsite,althoughmedicationmanagementandotherstrategiesareprovidedtothepatientsregardingHTNmanagement,theambulatorybloodpressuresoftheHTNpatientswithinthepastthreemonthscontinuedtoincrease.Aftercollaboratingwiththemedicaldirector,nursemanager,andseveralstaffnurses,itwasdecidedthatimplementingtheAHAguidelinesregardingaerobicexercisewouldbebeneficialtothepatients.
Chapter3re-introducestheproject’stopic,clinicalquestion,andproblemstatement.Otherchaptersegmentsincludetheprojectmethodology,design,andpopulationsample/size.Adiscussionoftheinstrument(AHAguidelinesforaerobicexercise),validity,andreliabilityaregiven.Thelastportionofthechaptergivesthedatacollectionandanalysisprocedures,potentialbiases,andmitigationprocedures.AfewsentencessummarizeChapter3andprovideapreludetoChapter4.
Statement of the Problem
It was not known if or to what degree the implementation “the American Heart Association’s” guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients.Theaffectedpopulationwereadultpatientsdiagnosedwithhypertension.ThecountywheretheclinicislocatedcorrespondswiththelatesthealthstatisticsfromtheTexasDepartmentofStateHealthServices(2022).Thecountyranks22ndintheUnitedStateswithdiagnosedHTNpatients(TexasDepartmentofStateHealthServices,2022).ThedemographicshighlightadiversepopulaceofBlacks(18.5%),Whites(28.9%),White-Hispanic(36.72%),Asians(6.9%),andLatinos(8.98.%)(U.S.CensusBureau,2020).Thecountyhasmanyindividualsover60diagnosedwithchronicdiseases(UTHealthScienceCenteratHouston,2020).Theadultagegroupsinthecountyrangefrom18to64,whichsignified the actual participants in the project.
Thisqualityimprovementprojectcontributestopreviousandcurrentliteratureregardingaerobicexercisebeingutilizedinhypertensionmanagement(Aung&Htay,2021;Kristetal.,2021;Saco-Ledoetal.,2020).TheCDC(2021)emphasizedthatfrequentphysicalexercisewasnecessaryforoverallwellness,mentalwell-being,andweightloss.Physicalactivitycouldimpactotherareasofone’slife,suchasreducingthesymptomsofanxietyanddepression(CDC,2021).
Aclinicalquestionisdevelopedfromaproblemorneedsthatcouldbeexaminedandevaluatedtoprovideusefulevidence-basedinformation(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Thefollowingclinicalquestionwillguidethisquantitativeproject:TowhatdegreedidtheimplementationofAmericanHeartAssociationguidelineaerobicexerciseimpactbloodpressurewhencomparedtocurrentpracticeamongadulthypertensivepatientsinaprimarycareclinicinsouthwestTexas within four weeks?TheindependentvariablewastheAmericanHeartAssociationguidelineregardingaerobicexercise,andthedependentvariable was blood pressures.
OncetheprojectmanagerreceivedpermissionfromGrandCanyonUniversityIRBandtheprojectsite,theprojectwasimplementedataprimarycareclinicinfourweeks.Aquasi-experimentaldesignallowedonetoassesstheimpactoftheAHAguidelineregardingaerobicexercise(independentvariable)ontheparticipants’bloodpressures(dependentvariable).Datawasretrievedfromtheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecordfourweeksbeforeandaftertheimplementationoftheintervention.Conveniencesamplingwasusedforeasieraccesstotheparticipantsandfacility.The project manager regarding the AHA guidelines for aerobic exercise in HTN patients educated one physician, two nurse practitioners, two registered nurses, and one medical assistant.
Thedatacollectionprocessconsistedofonegroup.Apatientidentifierwas assignedtoeachpatientandorganizedaccordingtothemeasurementperiod(preorpostimplementation).Theprojectmanagerusednumericcodesforallvariablesentered.Precodedasmeasurementperiod“1”andpostinterventioncodedasmeasurementperiod“2”.Thedatawas exportedbytheoutsidestatisticianintoIBMSPSSversion-28toevaluatethefrequencycounts,rangescores,andcheckedformissingdataandoutliers.TResults were evaluated in light of the AHA recommendations and their influence on participants’ blood pressure readings taken with the Oscar 2 Device ambulatory monitor.Anyhardcopiesofdemographicsorotherinformationwascollecteddailyandkeptinthemedicaldirector’sofficeinalockedfilecabinet.
Theinclusioncriteriaoftheparticipantsareadultpatients18andolder,diagnosedwithHTN,currentclinicpatients,andcanpartakeinphysicalactivity with difficulties.Theexclusioncriteriaareindividualswithmusculoskeletaldisabilities,comorbiditiesthatcouldaffecttheprojectresults,andmentaldisorders.
Aquantitativemethodologywasusedinthisqualityimprovementproject.Itwasthebestmethodandsuitableforanalyzingnumericaldata(StatisticalSolutions,2019).Furthermore,itallowedtheprojectmanagertoanswertheclinicalquestionbycomparingthebaselineandpost-interventionresults(Guetterman&Fetters,2018).Thismethodprovidesobjective,systematic,andfocuseddatacollectionandanalysisstrategies(Guetterman&Fetters,2018).Forthisproject,theAHA’sguidelinesforaerobicexercisewasevaluatedfortheirimpactonHTNpatients’bloodpressure.Thedependentvariable(bloodpressure)was measured four weeks using the Oscar 2 Device ambulatory blood pressure monitor before and post-intervention.
Aqualitativemethodologywasnotappropriateforthisproject.Theprojectmanagerdidnotfocusonunderstandingtheparticipants’behaviors,livedexperiences,orfeelings(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Themethodissubjectiveandthematic,withthefindingswrittenusingtheparticipants’wordsverbatim(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Dataisanalyzedutilizingacodingtechniquethatseeksthemesandpatterns(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Theresultsareshownintwoorthreecolumnsusingtheparticipant’swords.Thismethodistime-consuming,andasaresult,itisnotsuitableforaquality improvement project.Throughthestatisticalanalysis,thequantitativemethodhelpedestablishthedegreetowhichaerobicexercisescould sustain reductions in BP in hypertensive patients.
Aquasi-experimentaldesignwasselectedforthisproject.Thisdesignallowedtheprojectmanagertocomparetheindependentanddependentvariables(Creswell&Creswell,2018).ThedesignwasthemostappropriateinevaluatingthevariablesanddeterminingtheimpactoftheAHAguidelinesregardingaerobicexerciseontheparticipants’bloodpressures.Therespondentswere not randomly assigned to any group(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thebloodpressure(dependentvariable)was measuredtwotimesduringthedatacollectionprocess(fourweeksbeforeandaftertheintervention).
Acorrelationaldesignwasnotthemostappropriateforthisproject.Itisanon-experimentaldesignwheretheindependentanddependentvariablesaremeasuredandassessedfortheircorrelationrelationship(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Furthermore,theprojectmanagercannotcontrolthevariablesin correlational research design (Creswell&Creswell,2018).
DatafortheindependentvariablewerecollectedusingTheOscar2™AmbulatoryBloodPressureMonitormadebySunTechMedical®,Morrisville,NC(referredtoasOscar2afterward)(SunTechMedical,2021).ThisdevicewasusedtocreateanABPMlogforparticipants.ThisdevicehasbeenshowntoprovideaccuratereadingsforABP(Nwankwoetal.,2020).Baseline(pre-interventionmeasurements)weretakenonthefirstdayofthevisit, after education process.TheABPwasmeasuredattwopoints:baseline(pre-intervention)weeksoneandfour(post-intervention).AcomparisonofABPmeasuresatthesetwopointshelped todeterminetheextenttowhichtheimplementationofaerobicexerciseimpactedbloodpressurewhencomparedtocommonpractice(pretest)amongadulthypertensivepatients.RepeatedmeasureshelpeddetermineifaerobicexerciseseffectivelysustainedreductionsinBPinthetargetpopulation.
Thedatacollectiontoolchosenwastheclinicalobservationofoutcomes,whichentailedreviewingABPmeasurementsfromtheABPMlogofparticipants.TheOscar2devicekeepsadigitalABPlogthatcanberetrievedtoacomputertoshowarecordofABPmeasurementsthroughoutthedayandthe24-houraveragecalculated(SunTechMedical,2021).ThisdevicealsohasaninstructionmanualonhowitcouldbeusedforanABPmonitor.ThedigitalABPMdataensuredaccuracyandreliabilitysincesuchinformationisdevoidoferrorsthatarisewhenself-reporteddataareutilized(Nwankwoetal.,2020).
Population and Sample selection
ThetargetedpopulationforthisprojectconsistedofAmericanadultsdiagnosedwithhypertension.Anestimated45%ofAmericanadults,about116million,arehypertensive(CDC,2021).InTexas,theprevalenceofhypertensionis35.1%.HypertensionisprevalentintheU.S.andfrequentlyfoundinAfricanAmericans,Whites,Hispanics,andAsianAmericans(MillionHearts,2021).TheprojectpopulationcomprisedofhypertensivepatientsvisitingaprimarycareclinicinurbanTexas,whichwasthesettingforthisproject.Theclinicprovidesservicestoadiversepopulationbutpredominatelyseesminorities.Approximately20individualsareseenthreetimesperweekatthisclinic.
Conveniencesamplingwasemployedtoenrollparticipants.Thisformofselectionentailsselectingparticipantsbasedontheiraccessibilityandavailabilitytoparticipate(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thehealthcare staff at the clinic (registered nurse, nurse practitioner, medical assistant, and physician) implemented the project.Thosewhoexpressedinterestinparticipatingintheprojectwereprovidedadditionalinformationforparticipation.Themedicalassistant/nursecalledthepatientshighlightedonthedailylogforthenextdaywithhypertension.Thisindividualwasprovidedabriefdescriptionoftheprojectandhighlightthepatient’snameinblue(toletthehealthcareprovidersknowthepatientwasparticipatingintheproject).TheminimumsamplesizewasevaluatedusingG*Powersoftware,version3.1.9.2,usinganalphameasureof0.05,aneffectsizeof0.5,andapowerof80%computedtheleastnumberofparticipantsneededfortheproject(n=10).
Participantswereprovideinformedconsentbeforeparticipatingintheprojectbecausethisisaqualityimprovementproject,notaresearchstudy.AfteraverbalpresentationoftheprogrambyhealthcarestaffattheclinicaftertheyweretaughtusingaPowerPointpresentation.Participantswereprovidedwithaninformationsheetdetailingtheproject’spurpose,theintervention,andthenatureoftheirparticipation.Afterward,participantswhoexpressinterestinparticipatingintheprojectwere told that their information were de-identified.TheclinicdoesnothaveanIRB,soawrittenprocessandHealthcareInsurancePortabilityandAccountabilityAct(HIPAA)waiverformwas filledoutandsignedbyresponsiblepartiesforGrandCanyonUniversity’sIRBprocess.Theconfidentialityofparticipantswas guaranteedbyde-identifyingthecollecteddata.Patientde-identifierswere used instead of names. The inclusion criteria werebeingatleast18years,HTNdiagnosis,beingaTexasresident,andindependentlyseekinginterventiontomanageHTN,takingmedicationsforHTN.Patientsbelow18years,non-hypertensive,non-Texasresidents,nottakingHTNmedication,andwhocannotperformaerobicexerciseswere excluded from the project.
Instrumentation and Sources of Data
The data for this project were obtainedfrompatient’selectronicABPMlogretrievedfromtheOscar2device.Thisdevicewasalso programmedtoconductanABPmonitorwithapatientbyretrievingBPdatafromacomputer.Forthisproject,theintervalsfortakingABPreadingsontheOscar2devicewas 20 minutes after walking exercise.Anessentialaspectofusingthedevicewaspatientpreparationandeducation,whichfocusedonvariousaspects,includinghowtouseandtakecareofthedevicealthoughreadingwillbetakingintheclinicpre-andpost-implementation.BeforestartingtheABPproject,itwasimperativetoensurethatthedeviceoperatedasrequiredandwasinstalledcorrectlyonthepatient(Nwankwoetal.,2020).TheelectronicABPdataonthedevicewasretrievedfromacomputerviaaUSBcable.TheABPMlogwas formulatedfromthisdata,afterwhichthe24-hourABPaverageforaparticipantwascomputed.Atbaselineandpost-interventionparticipantswereprovidedwiththeOscar2devicetomonitortheirBPover24hours.Therewere nopermissionstousetheOscar2device,butthemanufacturehasabookletfordirectionsonhowtousethedeviceandcontactinformationincaseofmalfunction.Samplephotoofdevicewas furnished up on approval of the proposal by the IRB.
Validityreferstothedegreetowhichaconceptismeasuredaccurately.TheABPwasmeasuredusingtheOscar2device,whichwasreportedtobeavalidinstrument(Nwankwoetal.,2020).Nwankwoetal.(2020)comparedthreedifferentdevicesformeasuringBPreadings,whichincludedOscar2,Spacelabs90227(SL),andWelchAllynMobil-O-Graph(WA).ThiscomparisondidnotrevealanydifferencesinthepercentagesofvalidmeasurementsforBPacrossthethreedevices.TheOscar2devicesatisfiedtheminimumrequirementof70%ofaccurateBPmeasurementsfor24hours.Therefore,Oscar2isanaccurateandvalidatedinstrumentfortakingABPreadingsover24hours.
Reliabilityreferstotheaccuracyofaninstrument,whichisthedegreetowhichityieldsconsistentresultsifutilizedinthesamesituationrepeatedly.ThereliabilityoftheOscar2devicefortakingABPmeasurementswasestablished (Saco-Ledo et at , 2022). ThisdeviceisthefirstABMPsystemtoattainindependentvalidationbytheEuropeanSocietyofHypertensionprotocolsregardingtheaccuracyofABPmonitor(Stergiouetal.,2018).TheOscar2deviceoffersreliablemeasurementandrecordingofthe12-hourABPdata.Additionally,thedevicehasbeenreportedtobesufficientlyaccurateforregularclinicaluseindiversepatientpopulations.WhilefactorslikeHTNseverity,gender,weight,andageaffectABPmonitors’accuracy,thedifferencesareinsignificantinaffectingreliability.
Data Collection Procedures
AfterapprovalisreceivedfromGrandCanyonUniversityIRB,allpatientsvisitingtheclinicforhypertensionwhomettheinclusioncriteriawereaskedtoparticipateintheproject.The Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)waiver authorization form was signed between the PI and site contact person.Afterverbalrecruitmentbythehealthcarestaffattheclinic,participantswereprovidedwithaninformationsheetdetailingtheproject’spurpose,benefitsofparticipation,andrisks.Recruitmentoccurredforoneweek,andenrolledpatientswerefollowedforthefour-weekimplementationperiod.Forthisproject,patientswere not divided into groups; instead, data was collected four weeks before and four weeks after the implementation of the intervention.
TheOscar2devicewas usedtocollect24-hourABPdatafromparticipants.Thisdevicewasfittedtoparticipantsattheclinic.Attheendof24hours,healthcareprovidersremovedthedeviceatthefacility.DatafromOscar2were downloadedintoapassword-securecomputer,andde-identifiedinformationused to save them
.Thehealthcareproviderstookthe24-hourABPmeasurementsattwotimepoints:baselinewithoutaerobicexercise in weekone,andweekfourafterworkout.Thesemeasurementswerecomparedtodetermineifweeklyaerobicexercisereducedtheparticipant’sbloodpressure.
The participants wereinstructedthattheyareexpectedtopracticetheirwalkingathomethreetofivetimesweeklyfor20minutesandcontinuetotaketheirantihypertensivemedications.Theparticipantswere informed to continue their routine activities and method of communicating with their primary physician while on the project implementation.Participantstrackedtheirinvolvementviaalogbookduringtheirnon-clinicvisitday(Mondays,Wednesdays,andFridays) to show commitment. Those who have clinic appointments during this time performedtheirexerciseintheclinicwhilewaitingtobeseenbythephysician.
Inweekfour,participantsreturnedtotheclinictoretaketheirABPusingOscar2device.Participantsambulated around the clinic for 20 minuteswearingtheOscar2device.They were monitored for their walking, whether it was intense or moderate. The ABP measurements were takenaftera20-minuterestperiod by the staff.
Tomaintaindatasecurely,thedatacollectionwasmaintainedonapassword-protectedcomputerinalockedoffice.ThedatafilecontaineduniqueidentifiersthatdidnotcollectPHIforparticipants.Hardcopiesofpatientdatawerekeptinthelockedofficeinalockeddeskdrawerwhereinonlytheprimaryinvestigatorhasaccess.HardcopieswillbedestroyedusingGrandCanyonUniversity’sguidelinesthreeyearsfromthecompletiondate(August2025).Perthedatamanagementguidelinesofthefacility,datawillbedestroyedusingERASER(acomputersoftware)andIronMountaindocumentationshreddingservices.
The deidentified code book was senttoanoutsidestatisticiannotaffiliatedwiththeprojectusingencryptedemail.Theindependentvariableis“theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineforaerobicexercise,andthedependentvariablesaresystolicanddiastolicbloodpressure.Sincetheprojectdesigninvolvedamatchedsamplewithpre-andpost-implementationBPdata,pairedsamplest-testswereconductedtoaddresstheclinicalquestiontodetermineifthelevelsdeclinedaftertheintervention.Demographicswereanalyzedusingdescriptivestatistics.Thedatawere preparedusingtheStatisticalPackageforSocialSciences28(SPSS-28)fordataanalysis.
Data Analysis Procedures
Thefollowingclinicalquestiondirectedthisquantitativeproject:Towhatdegreedidtheimplementationof“theAmericanHeartAssociation’s”guidelineaerobicexercise impactbloodpressurewhencomparedtocurrentpracticeamongadulthypertensivepatientsinaprimarycareclinicinsouthwestTexas with four weeks?TheindependentvariableistheAmericanHeartAssociationguidelineregardingaerobicexercise,andthedependentvariableisbloodpressures.Descriptivedata(suchasage,gender,andethnicity)wascollectedviatheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecords.Theageswereanalyzedusingthemeanandstandarddeviation.Theparticipants’gender,ethnicity,anddiagnosiswereevaluatedusingfrequencycountsandpercentages.
Thedatawasretrievedfromtheclinic’selectronicmedicalrecordsandinsertedintoaMicrosoftExcelspreadsheet.Apatientidentifierwasassignedtoeachpatientandorganizedaccordingtothemeasurementperiod(preorpostimplementation).Theprojectmanagerusednumericcodesforallvariablesentered.Prewerecodedasmeasurementperiod“1”andpostinterventionwere codedasmeasurementperiod“2”.Theoutside statistician exported data into IBM SPSS version-28 to evaluate the frequency counts, range scores, and check for missing data and outliers.
The participants ’blood pressures( dependent variable)were analyzedusingapairedsample
t-testinweekfour.Theindependentvariablearenominal,andthedependentvariableareaninterval-levelvariable(Schober&Vetter,2019).This
t-testexaminesthemeanscorestakenfromthesameparticipants(Schober&Vetter,2019).Furthermore,thetestalignedwiththequasi-experimentaldesign,whichallowedtheprojectmanagertoassesstheimpactoftheintervention(AHAguidelinesforaerobicexercise)ontheoutcome(bloodpressures)inthetargetedpopulationbybeingrandomlyassigned.Thelevelofstatisticalsignificancewassetto.05toindicatethata
p-valueoflessthan.05 and considered statistically significant.
Apotentialselectionbiaswasexpectedduetotheuseofconveniencesampling.Selectionbiasinvolvessystematicallyexcludingsomeparticipantsfromthesamplewhenconvenienceandaccessibilityareutilizedtorecruitparticipants.Tomitigatethisbias,attemptsweremadetoensurethatthesampleisrepresentativebyensuringthatitmatchesthecharacteristicsofthepopulationintermsofcharacteristicssuchasgender,age,andethnicity.Quotaswereincorporatedtomakesurethatthesamplerepresentsthepopulation.Apossiblebiascouldoccurindatacollection,wheresomeparticipantscouldmisusetheOscar2device,yieldinginaccurateBPreadings.Thiswasminimizedbyeducatingthe staff and participantsonhowtousethedevicecorrectly.Duringdatainterpretation,analyticsbiascausedbyincompletedatasetswaslikely. Hence,anoutsidestatisticianconductedthedataanalysisprocedurestomitigatethisbias.
Ethical Considerations
AccordingtothethreeprinciplesdiscussedintheBelmontReport(1979)(respect,justice,andbeneficence),ethicalissuewasworthconsideringtoprotecttheparticipants’anonymity,confidentiality,andmaintainethics.Toensureanonymity,thecollecteddatawere de-identifiedbyremovingpersonalinformation.Confidentialityachievedbykeepingthedatainasecurecomputerthatispasswordencrypted.Thisinformationwas notsharedwithanyonenotinvolvedintheproject.Voluntaryparticipationwas achievedbyensuringthatparticipantsunderstandtheirrightsandareprovidedwithadequateinformationregardingtheprojecttomakeaninformedchoiceonwhethertoparticipatebutrequiringnoinformedconsent form.
Therearenoconflictsofinterestbecausenoentityfundedtheproject.Theprincipleofrespectrequiresensuringautonomy.Becausethisisaqualityimprovementproject,noconsentisrequiredfromtheparticipantsasitisvoluntary.Theprincipleofjusticerequiresequallydistributingtherisksandbenefitsoftheproject,whichwas achievedbyensuringthatallpatientspresentingwithHTNweregivenachancetoparticipatesothattheydidnotmissapotentiallybeneficialintervention.Beneficenceisaboutdoinggood.Thisprojectevaluatedapotentiallybeneficialintervention–aerobicsexercises.Uponapprovalofthedocumentbythechairpersonandthecommittee,theproposalwassubmittedforAQRreview.Thedata has beenkeptfollowingGrandCanyonUniversity’sIRBguidelines(threeyears)(August2025).Thecomputerdatawillbedestroyedusingcomputersoftware(ERASER)andthehardcopiesviaIronMountaindocumentationshreddingcompany.
Limitationsarecircumstancesorconditionsthattheprojectmanagercould notcontrol(Creswell&Creswell,2018).Thefirstlimitationofthisprojectwasthe
useofthequasi-experimentdesign.Thelackofrandomizationinthequasi-experimentaldesignshinderedtheabilitytomakecausalconnectionsbetweentheobservedoutcomeandtheinterventionimplemented(Creswell&Creswell,2018).
AsecondlimitationrelatedtosmallsamplerepresentativenessduetotheCOVID-19pandemic.Conveniencesamplingisnon-probabilistic,whichcanyieldanon-representativesample,thus,threateningexternalvalidity.Asmallsamplesizewouldimpacttheprojectresultsandincreasethemarginoferror(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Thesecondissuewithasmallsamplewasthatitcouldgeneratefalse-positiveresults(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).
Thethirdlimitationisthelimitedtimetoconducttheproject(fourweeks).Across-sectionalprojectprovidesasnapshotoftheintervention(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Alongitudinalprojectwouldallowonetoassesstheobstacles,changes,andtrendsthatoccurovertime(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).Furthermore,aninvestigatorcouldevaluateachronologicalsequenceofevents,whichestablishescausality(Leedy&Ormrod,2020).
ItwasnotknownifandtowhatextentAHAaerobicexerciserecommendationsreduceBPinadulthypertensivepatients.Theprojectaimedatinvestigatingtowhatextentaerobicexercisescouldalleviatebloodpressureinhypertensiveadults.TheindependentvariableforthisprojectistheAHAguidelinesonaerobicexercisesforhypertensivepatients.Ontheotherhand,thisproject’sdependentvariableistheparticipants’bloodpressuremeasurements.Themethodologyusedforthisprojectwasquantitative.Aquantitativemethodologywasutilizedbecauseitallowedstatisticalanalysisofnumericdatacollectedforthisprojectasbloodpressuremeasurements.Theprojectdesignisquasi-experimental,usingthewithin-groupdesign.Aquasi-experimentaldesignwasselectedasitisbothethicalandpracticalforthisproject.
Thedependentvariable,ABP,weremeasuredusingtheOscar2device,whichwere comparedduringthebaseline(pre-intervention)andpost-intervention(weekfour).Participantsweretakenusingconveniencesampling.Anormalsphygmomanometerwasavailableasasecondarytoolformeasuringtheparticipants’bloodpressure.Additionally,the10-itemBriefControlSelfScalebyTagneyetal.(2004)wasusedtoassessandselectparticipantswhoadheretotheaerobicexerciseroutineandtakebloodpressuremeasurements.Theselectioncriteriafortheparticipantsinvolvedadultswithhypertensionovertheageof18visitinganurbanclinicinsouthwestTexas.Themethodology’svalidityandreliabilityforthisprojectdependedonthetoolusedtomeasuretheparticipant’sbloodpressure.TheOscar2deviceproducedvalidandreliableresultsinmeasuringbloodpressure.TheparticipantsweretaughtabouttheOscar2deviceusingthesamemanufacturer’sbookletenclosedinthedevicepackage.
Chapter4deliveredthedescriptivedataoftheparticipants,datacollection,andanalysisprocedures.Theprojectfindingswere displayedusingfigures,tables,andsomenarrativeform.ThelastportionofthechaptersummarizestheresultsandpresentsanintroductiontoChapter5.
Chapter4: Data Analysis and Results
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC] (2022) suggests that regular physical movements or activities are critical for general wellness, weight loss, and one’s well-being. The recommendation by the CDC validates studies such as Krist et al. (2021) and Saco-Ledo et al. (2020) that aerobic exercise should be included in a patient’s hypertension management. The use of aerobic exercise, as noted by Saco-Ledo et al. (2020), emphasizes an individual’s systolic blood pressure by approximately 2 to 4 mm Hg in normotensive and 5 to 8 mm Hg in hypertension adult patients. It was not known if or to what degree the implementation of the American Heart Association guideline on aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients.
The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the implementation “the American Heart Association’s” guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks. The independent variable is the American Heart Association guideline on aerobic exercise, and the dependent variable is the blood pressure. The clinical question that directed the project was developed from the problem and purpose statements. To what degree does the implementation of American Heart Association guideline aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas? To answer the question, data was obtained from the patient’s electronic ABPM log retrieved from the Oscar 2 device and evaluated four weeks pre-implementation and four weeks post-implementation. The clinical staff was educated on using the American Heart Association guideline for aerobic exercise and the Oscar 2 device.
Chapter 4 summarizes the collected data and how it was analyzed. Other chapter segments include the problem statement, clinical question, and methodology. The results are presented in narrative form along with figures, tables. The last section of the chapter provided a preview of Chapter 5 and its contents.
Descriptive Data
The project site is a primary care clinic in urban Texas. A convenience sample of
n
= 10 adult patients with HTN were enrolled in the project. Descriptive data were collected for age, gender, and race. Table 1 displays the descriptive data for age. The mean age was 56.50 (
SD = 7.92) with a range from 43 to 71.
Table 1
Descriptive Data for Age
Variable |
Descriptive Data |
|
M |
SD |
|
Age |
56.50 |
7.92 |
Note. M = mean;
SD = standard deviation
Gender and race are displayed in Table 2. There were three males (30.0%) and females made up 70.0% (
n = 7). Race was 80.0% (
n = 8) African American, 10.0% (
n = 1) Hispanic, and 10.0% (
n = 1) Caucasian.
Table 2
Descriptive Data for Gender and Race
Variable |
Descriptive Data |
|
n |
% |
|
Gender |
||
Male |
3 |
30.0 |
Female |
7 |
70.0 |
Race |
||
African American |
8 |
80.0 |
Hispanic |
1 |
10.0 |
Caucasian |
1 |
10.0 |
Note: n = count; % = percentage
Data Analysis Procedures
This quality improvement project was implemented once approval was received from Grand Canyon University IRB and the clinic site. The following clinical question guided this quantitative project: To what degree does the implementation of American Heart Association guideline aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas? The independent variable was the American Heart Association guideline regarding aerobic exercise which was a nominal level variable, and the dependent variable was systolic and diastolic blood pressure, and blood pressure is a ratio-level variable. The clinic’s electronic medical records were used to collect descriptive data (age, gender, and race). The age was analyzed using the mean and standard deviation. The participants’ gender and ethnicity were evaluated using frequency counts and percentages.
Data on the patient outcomes for systolic and diastolic blood pressure were obtained from the clinic’s electronic medical records and inserted into a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet (codebook). Each participant was assigned a patient identifier and organized according to pre and post intervention measurement periods. The project manager used numeric codes for all variables entered. The pre-intervention measurement period was coded as “1,” and post-intervention was coded as measurement period “2”. An outside statistician exported the data into IBM SPSS version-28 to evaluate the frequency counts, range scores, and check for missing data and outliers and conduct statistical analysis.
The participants’ systolic and diastolic blood pressures (dependent variable) were analyzed using paired sample t-tests. This t-test was chosen for statistical analysis because it examines the mean scores taken from the same participants at two different measurement periods (Schober & Vetter, 2019). Furthermore, the test aligns with the quasi-experimental design, which allows the project manager to assess the impact of the intervention (AHA guidelines for aerobic exercise), on the outcome (systolic and diastolic blood pressure) in the convenience sample. The level of statistical significance was set to .05 to indicate that a p-value of less than .05 is considered statistically significant.
Results
The results are presented to address the clinical question related to the impact of the AHA guidelines for aerobic exercise on systolic and diastolic blood pressure. A paired
t-test
was conducted on systolic blood pressure at pre-and post-implementation and results are displayed in Table 3. The goal was to reduce ambulatory blood pressure after the intervention. The results showed a decrease in the mean systolic BP level from pre (
M = 152.60,
SD = 14.42) to post (
M = 126.10,
SD = 19.93),
t (9) = 6.35,
p = .001. The
p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean systolic BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by the 26.50 mean declines in the systolic mean levels after the intervention.
Table 3
Paired t-test results for Systolic Blood Pressure Levels
Variable |
Pre |
Post |
t (9) |
p |
||
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
|||
Systolic BP (mm/Hg) |
152.60 |
14.42 |
126.10 |
19.93 |
6.35 |
.001 |
Note. M = mean
; SD = standard deviation
A paired
t-test was conducted on diastolic blood pressure at pre-and post-implementation and results are displayed in Table 4. The results showed a decrease in the mean diastolic BP level from pre (
M = 87.30,
SD = 11.19) to post (
M = 78.10,
SD = 8.45)
, t (9) = 2.56,
p = .031. The
p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean diastolic BP was statistically significant.Clinicalsignificancewassupportedbythe9.20-point mean decline in the systolic mean levels after the intervention.
Table3
Paired t-test results for Diastolic Blood Pressure Levels
Variable |
Pre |
Post |
t (9) |
p |
||
M |
SD |
M |
SD |
|||
Diastolic BP (mm/Hg) |
87.30 |
11.19 |
78.10 |
8.45 |
2.56 |
.031 |
Note. M = mean
; SD = standard deviation
Data analysis was conducted on systolic and diastolic BP at pre and post implementation. The paired t-test results showed a
p-value of .001 for the systolic BP analysis and a
p-value of .031 for the diastolic BP analysis which indicates that the difference in mean scores was statistically significant. The results also support the clinical significance of the project as reflected in a 26.50-pointmean decline in the systolic and 9.20-point mean decline in diastolic scores after the physical activity intervention.
Summary
This quality improvement project aimed to evaluate the impact of using the American Heart Association guideline on the participants’ blood pressures. The setting was a primary care clinic in Southwest Texas. A convenience sample of
N = 10 adult patients with HTN were enrolled in the project. The mean age was 56.50 (SD= 7.92) with a range from 43 to 71. There were three males (30.0%) and females made up 70.0% (
n = 7). Race was 80.0% (n = 8) African American, 10.0% (n = 1) Hispanic, and 10.0% (n = 1) Caucasian.
Blood pressures were obtained from the electronic medical records which recorded the Oscar 2 device ABPM log. Paired samples t-tests were conducted to analyze the blood pressure scores to see if they declined after the intervention. The results showed a decrease in the mean systolic BP level from pre (
M = 152.60,
SD = 14.42) to post (
M = 126.10,
SD = 19.93),
t (9) = 6.35,
p = .001. There was also a decrease in the mean diastolic BP level from pre (
M = 87.30,
SD = 11.19) to post (
M = 78.10,
SD = 8.45)
, t (9) = 2.56,
p =.031.The
p-value for both outcomes was less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by a 26.50-pointmean decline in the systolic and 9.20-point mean decline in diastolic scores after the AHA physical activity intervention.
Chapter 5 reestablished the project’s aim and its summary. The chapter discussed the project findings and examined how they answered the clinical question. Other sections of the chapter included the implications (theoretical, practical, and future) for quality improvement projects and clinical practices. The last segment of the chapter presented recommendations for potential improvement projects and healthcare settings.
Chapter 5: Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations
Hypertension (HTN) remains one of the preventable causes of death (Song et al., 2020). It is a disease risk factor for cardiac issues, heart failure, and cerebrovascular accidents (Song et al., 2020). The prevalence of HTN continues to increase globally and particularly in American adults affecting over half of them (37 million individuals) (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2021; Krist et al., 2021; Song et al., 2020). The disease is dangerous because it is considered the “silent killer” (CDC, 2021).The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the implementation “the American Heart Association’s” guideline on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks. At the clinical site, the project manager, Medical Director, and clinic manager collaborated regarding the increased ambulatory blood pressures noted within the past three months. The standard of care at the site is through medication management for their condition. Hence, a unanimous decision was made to utilize a new strategy, implementing the American Heart Association’s guidelines on aerobic exercise to influence hypertensive patients.
Chapter 5 reintroduced the project’s topic and summarized the project. Other chapter segments included a summary of the project’s findings and conclusion, theoretical, practical, and future implications. The last portion of the chapter offered recommendations for future quality improvement projects and clinical practices.
Summary of the Project
This quality improvement project was conducted utilizing a quantitative methodology and quasi-experimental design in four weeks. Chapter 1 presented studies such as Adam and Wright (2020), Aung and Htay (2021), Krist et al. (2021), and Saco-Ledo et al. (2020) related to incorporating aerobic exercise to be included in an individual’s HTN management plan. The project contributed to the current body of literature, such as Aung and Htay (2021), Krist et al. (2021), and Saco-Ledo et al. (2020), regarding aerobic exercise being included in hypertension management. The impacted population was adults diagnosed with hypertension in a primary care clinic. The county’s demographics revealed that roughly 60,000 seniors 65 and older comprise the county’s populace (Data USA, 2019). In Texas, the incidence of HTN is at 35.1%, which validates findings from the CDC (2021) and Million Hearts (2021).
Chapter 2 discussed Orem’s self-care deficit theory and Lewin’s change model are the theoretical underpinnings for this quality improvement project. Orem’s self-care theory was chosen because it focused on the reciprocal relationship between humans and their environment (Orem, 1995). The theory highlighted that a human could provide self-care, and the primary goal of the healthcare provider should assist them in achieving an optimal level of independence (Orem, 1995). The nursing theory comprises five constructs: universal self-care requisites, normalcy, developmental self-care requisites, and health deviation self-care requisite (Orem, 1995). Implementing this theory permitted the project manager to guide the clinicians regarding their responsibilities in providing the patient with a transparent plan of care. This helped the HTN patients to sustain an appropriate level of self-care (Orem, 1995).
Lewin’s change model was selected for this quality improvement project. It was chosen because it emphasized the need for change for clinicians and HTN patients impacted by restraining forces (Lewin, 1947). The change model consists of three phases: unfreezing, change (movement), and refreezing (Lewin, 1947). The first phase, unfreezing, began when the project manager collaborated with the nursing manager, medical director, and a few nursing staff to detect the increase in ambulatory blood pressures in HTN patients within the past three months. The second phase, changing (movement), began when the project manager educated the staff to use the implementation of the American Heart Association (AHA) guidelines related to aerobic exercise. During the phase, the patients were educated by the staff, clinicians were trained, and the project was monitored. The last stage, refreezing, began when the discussion about the AHA guidelines became infused into the organizational culture and a daily habit in the healthcare providers’ clinical practice (Lewin, 1947).
The project was implemented once approval was received from Grand Canyon University IRB and the project site. It was implemented in four weeks to examine the impact of AHA guidelines related to aerobic exercise on ambulatory blood pressures. The project came after collaboration with the medical director and some nursing staff showed an increase of 37.1% in diagnosed HTN patients within the past six months. The project contributed to the current body of literature regarding the impact of aerobic exercise on decreasing one’s hypertension (Aung &Htay, 2021; Krist et al., 2021; Saco-Ledo et al., 2020). Other areas affected by regular aerobic exercise are weight loss, improved well-being, and decreased symptoms of depression and anxiety (CDC, 2022).
The staff consisted of one physician, two nurse practitioners, two registered nurses, and one medical assistant. They were educated regarding using the AHA guidelines for aerobic exercise for 30-minute using a slide presentation and provided a brochure explaining the process. In week one, recruitment for the project occurred, with each participant being offered an information sheet that detailed the project’s purpose, benefits, and risks. Patients were given the knowledge about the HIPAA waiver form and their voluntary participation in the project. The participants’ initial blood pressure was taken with an Oscar 2 device as the pre-test, then the participant carried out the aerobic exercise workout in weeks two and three, and post-test blood pressure measurement was taken by the end of the fourth week.
The project manager offered support to the staff regarding the project and reviewed the data collected using the electronic medical record. In week four, each respondent’s aerobic blood pressure was taken and documented in their electronic medical record. In weeks one and four, blood pressure measurements were compared to determine if weekly aerobic exercise impacted the respondent’s blood pressure. A codebook was developed using a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet. The document was sent via encrypted email to a statistician not affiliated with the project or project manager. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze the demographics, and a paired samples t-test was conducted to determine the statistical significance of the intervention.
Summary of Findings and Conclusion
The clinical question that directed the project: To what degree did the implementation of American Heart Association guideline aerobic exercise did impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas within four weeks? The independent variable was the American Heart Association guideline regarding aerobic exercise, and the dependent variable was blood pressure. The question was answered using a paired t-test conducted on systolic blood pressure pre, and post-implementation. This quality improvement project aimed to evaluate the impact of using the American Heart Association guideline on the participants’ blood pressures. It was hoped that the participants’ blood pressures would decline after the AHA guideline intervention. The setting was a primary care clinic in Southwest Texas. A convenience sample of
N = 10 adult patients diagnosed with HTN were enrolled in the project. The mean age was 56.50 (SD= 7.92) with a range from 43 to 71. There were three males (30.0%) and females made up 70.0% (
n = 7). Race was 80.0% (n = 8) African American, 10.0% (n = 1) Hispanic, and 10.0% (n = 1) Caucasian.
Blood pressures were obtained from the electronic medical records which recorded the Oscar 2 device ABPM log and analyzed in IBM SPSS using paired samples t-tests.
The results showed a decrease in the mean systolic BP level from pre (
M =152.60,
SD = 14.42) to post (
M = 126.10,
SD = 19.93),
t (9) = 6.35,
p = .001
. A paired
t-test also showed a decline in the mean diastolic BP level from pre (
M = 87.30,
SD = 11.19) to post (
M = 78.10,
SD = 8.45)
, t (9) = 2.56,
p =.031.The
p-value for both outcomes was less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by a 26.50-pointmean decline in the systolic and 9.20-point mean decline in diastolic scores after the AHA physical activity intervention was implemented.
The American College of Cardiology (ACC) disclosed that physical exercise education and participation should be seen as a way of improving health, modifying lifestyle, and maintaining blood pressure as essential to preventing hypertension (ACC, 2022). While hypertension is serious, it is also attributed to other chronic conditions such as stroke, heart failure, impair mobility, daily function, and death if not effectively managed. Hence, hypertension and the use of daily physical activity to main health and manage blood pressure cannot be overemphasized.
Implications
The nursing field is a discipline that requires research, which concentrates on issues that affect the nursing practice (Polit & Beck, 2021). Nursing implications are essential in considering when to begin a new medication, intervention, or procedure (Polit & Beck, 2021). Healthcare providers who understand the potential impact they could have on the clinical practice, nursing care, and the patient allows them to provide the best quality care (Polit & Beck, 2021). The implications discussed in the following sections were developed on the project findings.
Theoretical Implications
Orem’s self-care deficit theory was selected and used for this quality improvement project. It was selected because it underlines the relationship between the patient and their environment (Orem, 1995). The theory states that humans can participate in their self-care and decision-making to improve their chronic or acute disease processes (Orem, 1995). This can be achieved by the healthcare providers guiding the patient using a patient-centered approach to help them gain an optimal level of independence related to hypertension (Orem, 1995). The theory’s four constructs comprise universal self-care requisites, normalcy, developmental self-care requisites, and health deviation self-care requisite (Orem, 1995). The theory allowed the project manager to help the clinicians understand their responsibilities while providing a transparent outline plan of care.
Lewin’s change model was chosen to work with Orem’s self-care deficit theory. The model revealed how HTN patients, and their healthcare providers are impacted by restraining forces (Lewin, 1947). The model consists of three phases: unfreezing, change (movement), and refreezing (Lewin, 1947). Unfreezing occurred once the project manager began the collaboration process with the medical director, nurse manager, and a few nursing staff to identify the problem (elevated ambulatory blood pressures over the past three months) and develop a plan (Lewin, 1947). The changing stage (movement) began when the project intervention (AHA guidelines related to aerobic exercise) was implemented (Lewin, 1947). The healthcare providers educated their patients using a patient-centered approach and monitoring them. Refreezing began integrating the intervention into the organization’s clinical practice until it became a habit (Lewin, 1947).
One strength noted while conducting the project was the buy-in of the healthcare providers to implement the intervention. Buy-in occurred because the project manager discussed and asked the staff for feedback and genuinely listened with an open mind to the suggestions. This made them feel valued and an intricate part of the intervention. The project clearly explained the project plan, timeline, and process for a successful implementation. The second strength was the healthcare providers offering a patient-centered approach to the various and preferred aerobic training. Some of the aerobic training used was walking, running, swimming, and cycling during the patient’s time completing the intervention at home. The aerobic training and intensity were increased if the patient could tolerate them weekly.
The weakness of the project was the time to conduct the project (four weeks). A longitudinal project is more powerful than a cross-sectional (Leedy& Ormrod, 2020). This method would have allowed the project manager to evaluate the variable patterns, trends, and obstacles that occurred over time (Leedy& Ormrod, 2020). It would have ensured focus, flexibility, and validity (Leedy& Ormrod, 2020).
Practical Implications
The first practical implication includes the clinical site hiring two case managers to continue the HTN patient’s care. This would involve providing patient resources, developing personalized care programs, and decreasing decentralized patient care (Song et al., 2020). Additionally, using the case managers can increase the patient’s knowledge regarding the disease, help them adhere to the treatment plans, while helping them improve their quality of life.
The second implication is for the clinicians to consider evaluating the patient’s health literacy level during the education process. Low health literacy is a silent epidemic and a subject many patients and families will not discuss; hence healthcare providers should have a simple and fast method to identify patients at risk of not understanding the information given. The assessment could occur utilizing the Newest Vital Sign developed by Pfizer Corporation. The six-item tool is based on the nutrition on an ice cream label and takes less than three minutes to administer. The scoring for the test is zero to six (0 to 1; there is a high likelihood of limited health literacy, 2 to 3 correct answers indicate a possibility of limited health literacy, and a score of 4 to 6 indicates adequate health literacy) (Weiss et al., 2005). Based on the number of correct answers provided, clinicians can evaluate the individual’s health literacy level and adjust the communication style and level with the patient to ensure understanding of the material.
The third implication is for clinicians to use an interactive pictorial wheel to improve self-management in HTN patients. This educational style using pictures can help patients discuss their personalized approach to managing HTN without feeling belittled or embarrassed. Furthermore, this method has been adapted for other diseases such as asthma, heart failure, and stroke (Gan et al., 2022). This communication style would be beneficial for individuals with low health literacy levels. The communication wheel would be based on medication, exercise, weight management, diet, and complications
Future Implications
One future implication is reproducing the project in other healthcare settings, such as prisons and outpatients. The second implication is for nurse managers to pay attention to the HTN risk in their older employees (age 40 and above) while providing regular blood pressure checks. The third implication is for clinicians to encourage patients to implement moderate resistance or strength training two days a week in combatting hypertension. The last implication is for healthcare providers to evaluate their patient’s life stressors and family environment. The stressors could include a terminal illness, recent death of a spouse or sibling, loss of job or home, and the long-term effects of COVID-19.
Recommendations
Nursing recommendations provide guidelines for advanced practice nurses to improve the quality of care and delivery to their patients. The recommendations discussed below are based on the project results. The project focused on the HTN population; however, the goal is to increase HTN knowledge among other healthcare providers and disciplines.
Recommendations for Future Projects
The first recommendation is to conduct a mixed-method study (qualitative/quantitative). This methodology would incorporate an observational and qualitative interview element. A qualitative approach would offer a broader view of the quantitative findings, which rely solely on numerical data from electronic medical records. Furthermore, it would capture the fluctuating attitudes within the HTN population (Leedy& Ormrod, 2020).
The second recommendation is for future quality improvement projects to identify patients with HTN and intervene with a focus on the patient’s lifestyle. Using an evidence-based survey or developing a lifestyle tool that examines the patient’s lifestyle changes in managing their HTN. This strategy could show the association with their blood pressure readings. Also, it is a cost-effective method for assessing the patient post-intervention. The third recommendation is to focus on patient follow-up. Many HTN patients do not return for follow-up appointments, helping them manage their condition. Unfortunately, for many clinics, it is not considered a priority; however, it remains an element of providing high-quality patient-centered care.
This project is then forwarded for the healthcare providers to deliver patient care using culturally competent care for this populace. Unfortunately, many of the patients seen at the clinic are from Black and Brown communities. As mentioned in Chapter 1, the project site’s demographics show a high population of Hispanics (36.72%) and Black people (18.5%). This confirms the statistics found by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2022), Hispanics (39%), and Black people (56%).
Recommendations for Practice
The first recommendation for future advanced nursing practices is to implement cultural competency that uses a cross-cultural approach in treating HTN patients. Health care providers play a significant role in how the patient interacts, experiences, and remains compliant with the suggested HTN regimen (Jongen et al., 2018). For many patients, cultural or linguistic differences between the provider and themselves could result in serious miscommunication, develop mistrust, and affect patient satisfaction (Jongen et al., 2018). The project findings revealed a high influx of Black and Brown patients being treated for the condition. Addressing the healthcare providers’ cultural competence is one way of improving health service and quality care for culturally diverse patients. Classes should be offered annually to clinicians regarding their knowledge, behavior, and attitudes to other populations (Jongen et al., 2018). Furthermore, it should involve the practitioners increasing their awareness regarding sexuality, gender, racism, and healthcare disparities (Jongen et al., 2018).
The second recommendation is to implement motivational interviewing in treating HTN patients. Approximately one-third of HTN patients obtain and sustain blood pressure control (Silveira et al., 2019). Motivational interviewing, created by Miller and Rollnick, focuses on a directive counseling and patient-centered strategy that promotes the individual’s desire to change (Silveira et al., 2019). Healthcare providers would follow the guidelines such as a) listening with empathy, b) being flexible with the patient’s resistance to change, c) resisting argumentation or confrontation, and d) encouraging optimism (Silveira et al., 2019). Using this approach could help to facilitate compliance with the HTN treatment.
The third recommendation is for clinicians to implement mobile apps and technology in educating their patients. For many patients, the discharge process consists of lots of information and terminology they do not understand. Utilizing their smartphones or tablets could make a difference in receiving and understanding the information without pressure or embarrassment regarding their health literacy level. The education would be given in short intervals (four weeks or less) with messages sent to the patient once a week or more dependent on the patient’s need (Timmers et al., 2020).
The fourth recommendation is for healthcare providers and organizations to offer collaborative environments where nurses and other disciplines can learn and practice treating patients diagnosed with HTN. This would include nursing at all levels, from students, and nursing assistants to nursing leaders. The pharmacist, nurse, nutritionist, and patient should also be part of this collaboration team. Smartphones and the internet should also increase team participation to improve communication and efficiency.
References
Adams,J.,&Wright,J.(2020).AnationalcommitmenttoimprovethecareofpatientswithhypertensionintheU.S.
JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,324(18),1825-1826.doi:10.1001/jama.2020.20356
Aggarwal,R.,&Ranganathan,P.(2019).Studydesigns:Part2,descriptivestudies.
PerspectiveClinicalResearch,10,34-36.
http://www.picronline.org/text
AmericanCollegeofCardiology.(2022).
HarmonizationofACC/AHAandESC/ESHBPhypertensionguidelines.https://www.acc.org/Latest-in-Cardiology/ten-points-to-remember/2022/08/22/16/48/Harmonization-of-the-ACC-A
AmericanHeartAssociation.(2022).
HistoryoftheAmericanHeartAssociation.
https://www.heart.org/en/about-us/history-of-the-american-heart-association
Anstey,D.,Bradley,C.,&Shimbo,D.(2021).USPSTFrecommendationstatementonhypertensionscreeninginadults:Wheredowegofromhere?
JournalofAmericanMedicalAssociationNetworkOpen,4(4),e214203-e214203.
https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2021.4203
Asayama,K.,Fujiwara,T.,Hoshide,S.,Ohkubo,T.,Kario,K.,Stergiou,G.,&Imai,Y.(2019).Nocturnalbloodpressuremeasuredbyhomedevices:Evidenceandperspectiveforclinicalapplication.
JournalofHypertension,37(5),905-916.doi:10.1097/HJH.0000000000001987
Aung,K.,&Htay,T.(2021).USPSTFfoundinsufficientevidenceonbenefitsandharmsofscreeningforvitaminDdeficiencyinasymptomaticadults.
AnnalsofInternalMedicine,174(9),1-3.
https://doi.org/10.7326/ACPJ202109210-100
Beaney,T.,Burrell,L.,Castillo,R.,Charchar,F.,Cro,S.,Damasceno,A.,Kruger,R.,Nilsson,P.,Prabhakaran,D.,Ramirez,A.,Schlaich,M.,Schutte,A.,Tomaszewski,M.,Touyz,R.,Wang,J.,Weber,M.,Poulter,N.,&MMMInvestigators.(2019).Maymeasurementmonth2018:ApragmaticglobalscreeningcampaigntoraiseawarenessofbloodpressurebytheInternationalSocietyofHypertension.
EuropeHeartJournal,40(25),2006-2017.doi:10.1093/eruheartj/ehze00.
Blumenthal,J.,Sherwood,A.,Smith,P.,&Hinderliter,A.(2018).Theroleofsaltreductioninthemanagementofhypertension.
JournaloftheAmericanCollegeofCardiology,
71(14),1597-1598.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacc.2018.01.071
Burnier,M.,&Egan,B.(2019).Adherenceinhypertension.
CirculationResearch,124(7),1124-1140.doi:10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.118.313220
Cameron,J.,Voth,J.,Jaglal,S.,Guiltier,S.,Hawker,G.,&Salbach,N.(2018).Inthistogether:Socialidentificationpredictshealthoutcomes(viaself-efficacy)inachronicdiseaseself-managementprogram.
SocialScience&Medicine,208,172-179.doi:10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.03.007
Carey,M.,&Forsyth,A.(2022).
Self-efficacyteachingtipsheet.[online]
https://www.apa.org/pi/aids/resources/education/self-efficacy
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2019).
Leadingcausesofdeath:1999-2019.NationalCenterforHealthStatistics.https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/leading-causes-ofdeath
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2020,October22).
TheSurgeonGeneral’scalltoactiontocontrolhypertension.
https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/CTA.htm
CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.(2021).
FactsabouthypertensionintheUnitedStates.https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/facts.htm
Chobufo,M.D.,Gayam,V.,Soluny,J.,Rahman,E.U.,Enoru,S.,Foryoung,J.B.,Agbor,V.N.,Dufresne,A.,&Nfor,T.(2020).PrevalenceandcontrolratesofhypertensionintheUSA:2017-2018.
InternationalJournalofCardiologyHypertension,6(2020),10044-10049.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijchy.2020.100044
Commodore-Mensah,Y.,Selvin,E.,Aboagye,J.,Turkson-Ocran,R.,Li,X.,Himmelfarb,C.,Ahima,R.,&Cooper,L.(2018).Hypertension,overweight/obesity,anddiabetesamongimmigrantsintheUnitedStates:Ananalysisofthe2010–2016nationalhealthinterviewsurvey.BMCPublicHealth,18(1),1-8.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5683-3
Creswell,J.W.,&Creswell,J.D.(2018).
Researchdesign:Qualitative,quantitative,andmixedmethodsapproaches(5thed.).SagePublications.
Dadlani,A.,Madan,K.,&Sawhney,J.(2018).Ambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringinclinicalpractice.
IndianHeartJournal,71(1),91-97.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ihj.2018.11.015.
DataUSA.(2019).
HarrisCounty,Tx.https://datausa.io/profile/geo/harris-county-tx/
Forde,A.,Sims,M.,Mutner,P.,Lewis,T.,Onwuka,A.,&Moore,K.(2020).DiscriminationandhypertensionriskamongAfricanAmericansintheJacksonheartstudy.
Hypertension,76(3),715-723.https://doi.org/10.1161/hypertensionaha.119.14492
Fotokian,Z.,Nasresabetghadam,S.,Jahanshahi,M.,Nasiri,M.,&Hajiahmadi,M.(2021).TheeffectsofOrem’sself-caretheoryonself-carebehaviorsamongolderwomenwithhypertension:Arandomizedcontrolledtrial.
NursingandMidwiferyStudies,
10(2),99-108.
https://doi.org/10.4103/nms.nms_9_20
Fuchs,F.,&Whelton,P.(2020).Highbloodpressureandcardiovasculardisease.Hypertension,75(2),285-292.
https://doi.org/10.1161/hypertensionaha.119.14240
Gan,W.,Zhang,Q.,Yang,D.,Yin,J.,Wang,Y.,Song,L.,Chen,T.,&Qi,H.(2022).Abehaviorchangewheel-basedinteractivepictorialhealtheducationprogramforhypertensivepatientswithlowbloodpressurehealthliteracy:Studyprotocolforarandomizedcontrolledtrial.
Trials,
23(1),1-30.https://doi.org/10.1186/s13063-022-06300-1
Ghatage,T.,Goyal,S.,Dhar,A.,&Bhat,A.(2021).Noveltherapeuticsforthetreatmentofhypertensionanditsassociatedcomplications:Peptide-andnonpeptide-basedstrategies.HypertensionResearch,44(7),740-755.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41440-021-00643-z
González-dePaz,L.,Kostov,B.,delCarmeAlviraBalada,M.,Colungo,C.,García,N.,Roura,S.,Blat,E.,Sierra-Benito,C.,Sotoca-Momblona,J.,Benavent-Areu,J.,Sánchez,E.,&Sisó-Almirall,A.(2019).Effectivenessofanewone-hourbloodpressuremonitoringmethodtodiagnosehypertension:Adiagnosticaccuracyclinicaltrialprotocol.
BritishMedicalJournal,9(5),1-6.doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2019-029268
GrandCanyonUniversity.(2021).
Research:Collegeofdoctoralstudies.
https://www.gcu.edu/college-of-doctoral-studies/doctoral-research.php
Guetterman,T.,&Fetters,M.(2018).Twomethodologicalapproachestotheintegrationofmixedmethodsandcasestudydesigns:Asystematicreview.
AmericanBehavioralScientist,62,900-918.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764218772641
Guirguis-Blake,J.,Evans,C.,Webber,E.,Coppola,E.,Perdue,L.,&Weyrich,M.(2021).Screeningforhypertensioninadults:UpdatedevidencereportandsystematicreviewfortheU.S.PreventiveServicesTaskForce.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation
,325(16),1657-1669.doi:10.1001/jama.2020.21669
Harrison,R.,Fischer,S.,Walpola,R.,Chauhan,A.,Babalola,T.,Mears,S.,&Le-Dao,H.(2021).Wheredomodelsforchangemanagement,improvementandimplementationmeet?Asystematicreviewoftheapplicationsofchangemanagementmodelsinhealthcare.
JournalofHealthcareLeadership,
13,85-108.
https://doi.org/10.2147/jhl.s289176
Henry,E.,Robertshaw,S.,&Stephenson,J.(2021).Improvingaccessibilitytooutpatientclinicsforadultswithsuspectedseizuresfromtheemergencydepartment:Aqualityimprovementproject.
Seizures,93,160-168. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.seizure.2021.10.023.
Hoffmann,M.,Nilsson,P.,Ahlner,J.,Dahllöf,B.,Fredrikson,M.,Säljö,R.,&Kjellgren,K.(2020).Dopatientsortheirphysiciansmoreaccuratelyassesslong-termriskassociatedwithhypertension?Apopulation-basedstudy.
ScandinavianJournalofPrimaryHealthCare,
38(2),166-175.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02813432.2020.1753345
Jiang,Y.,&Wang,W.(2021).Healthpromotionandself-managementamongpatientswithchronicheartfailure.HealthPromotioninHealthCare:VitalTheoriesandResearch,269-285.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-63135-2_19
Jongen,C.,McCalman,J.,&Bainbridge,R.(2018).Healthworkforceculturalcompetencyinterventions:Asystematicscopingreview.
BMCHealthServicesResearch,
18(1),1-16.
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-018-3001-5
Khademian,Z.,Kazemi,F.,&Gholamzadeh,S.(2020).Theeffectofself-careeducationbasedonOrem’snursingtheoryonqualityoflifeandself-efficacyinpatientswithhypertension:Aquasi-experimentalstudy.
InternationalJournalofCommunity-BasedNursingandMidwifery,8(2),140-149.https://doi.org/10.30476/IJCBNM.2020.81690.0
Kirkland,E.,Heincelman,M.,Bishu,K.,Schumann,S.,Schreiner,A.,Axon,R.,Mauldin,P.,&Moran,W.(2018).TrendsinhealthcareexpendituresamongUSadultswithhypertension:Nationalestimates,2003–2014.JournaloftheAmericanHeartAssociation,7(11),1-6.
https://doi.org/10.1161/jaha.118.008731
Kivunja,C.(2018).Distinguishingbetweentheory,theoreticalframework,andconceptualframework:Asystematicreviewoflessonsfromthefield.
InternationalJournalofHigherEducation,
7(6),44–53.
https://doi.org/10.5430/ijhe.v7n6p44
Kramer,H.,Townsend,R.,Griffin,K.,Flynn,J.,Weiner,D.,Rocco,M.,&Beddhu,S.(2019).KDOQIUScommentaryonthe2017ACC/AHAhypertensionguideline.
AmericanJournalofKidneyDiseases,73(4),437-458.doi:10.1053/j.ajkd.2019.01.007.
Krist,A.,Davidson,K.,Mangione,C.,Cabana,M.,Caughey,A.,Davis,E.,Donahue,K.,Doubeni,C.,Kubik,M.,Li,L.,Ogedegbe,G.,Pbert,L.,Silverstein,M.,Stevermer,J.,Tseng,C.,&Wong,J.(2021).Screeningforhypertensioninadults.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,325(16),1650-1656.
https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.4987
Leedy,P.,&Ormrod,J.(2020).
Practicalresearch:Planninganddesign.PearsonPublications.
Lewin,K.(1947).Frontiersingroupdynamics:concept,method,andrealityinsocialscience;socialequilibriaandsocialchange.
HumanRelations,1,5–41.
https://doi.org/10.1177/001872674700100103
Lurbe,E.,Agabiti-Rosei,E.,Cruickshank,J.,Dominiczak,A.,Serap,E.,Invitti,C.,Mancia,G.,Denes,P.,Wolfgang,R.,Schaefer,F.,Tomas,S.,Manish,S.,Stella,S.,Webb,N.,Wühl,E.,&Zanchetti,A.(2016).2016EuropeanSocietyofHypertensionguidelinesforthemanagementofhighbloodpressureinchildrenandadolescents.
JournalofHypertension,10,1887-1920.doi:10.1097/HJH.0000000000001039
Mandini,S.,Conconi,F.,Mori,E.,Myers,J.,Grazzi,G.,&Mazzoni,G.(2018).Walkingandhypertension:Greaterreductionsinsubjectswithhigherbaselinesystolicbloodpressurefollowingsixmonthsofguidedwalking.
PeerJournal,6(1),1-13.
https://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.5471
MayoClinic.(2021,July1).
Highbloodpressure(hypertension):Diagnosisandtreatment.
https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/high-blood-pressure/diagnosis-treatment/drc-20373417
Miao,H.,Liu,Y.,Tsai,T.,Schwartz,J.,&Ji,J.(2020).AssociationbetweenbloodleadlevelanduncontrolledhypertensionintheUSpopulation(NHANES1999–2016).
JournaloftheAmericanHeartAssociation,9(13),1-26.
https://doi.org/10.1161/jaha.119.015533
MillionHearts.(2021,March22).
HypertensionprevalenceintheU.S.CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention.
https://millionhearts.hhs.gov/data-reports/hypertension-prevalence.html
Muntner,P.,Hardy,S.,Fine,L.,Jaeger,B.,Wozniak,G.,Levitan,E.,&Colantonio,L.(2020).TrendsinbloodpressurecontrolamongUSadultswithhypertension,1999-2000to2017-2018.JournaloftheAmericanMedicalAssociation,324(12),1190-1193.
https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2020.14545
Nerenberg,K.,Zarnke,K.,Leung,A.,Dasgupta,K.,Butalia,S.,McBrien,K.,Harris,K.,Nakhla,M.,Cloutier,L.,Gelfer,M.,Lamarre-Cliché,M.,Milot,A.,Bolli,P.,Tremblay,G.,McLean,D.,Padwai,R.,Tran,K.,Grover,S.,Rabki,S&Daskalopoulou,S.(2018).HypertensionCanada’s2018guidelinesfordiagnosis,riskassessment,prevention,andtreatmentofhypertensioninadultsandchildren.
CanadianJournalofCardiology,34(5),506-525.doi:10.1016/j.cjca.2018.02.022
Nwankwo,T.,ColemanKing,S.M.,Ostchega,Y.,Zhang,G.,Loustalot,F.,Gillespie,C.,&Merritt,R.(2020).Comparisonof3devicesfor24-hourambulatorybloodpressuremonitoringinanonclinicalenvironmentthrougharandomizedtrial.
AmericanJournalofHypertension,33(11),1021-1029.https://doi.org/10.1093/ajh/hpaa117
Oprail,S.(2016).Hypertensioninwomen:Moredangerousthaninmen?
JournalHypertension,9(34),1-15.doi:10.1097/01.hjh.0000500943.95477.bd
Orem,D.(1995).
Nursing: Concepts of practice (4thed.).Mosby.
Polit,D.,&Beck,C.(2018).Essentialsofnursingresearch:Appraisingevidencefornursingpractice.LWW.
Rêgo,M.,Cabral,D.,Costa,E.,&Fontes,E.(2019).Physicalexerciseforindividualswithhypertension:Itistimetoemphasizeitsbenefitsonthebrainandcognition.
ClinicalMedicineInsights:Cardiology,
13,1-8.
https://doi.org/10.1177/1179546819839411
Saco-Ledo,G.,Valenzuela,P.,Ruiz-Hurtado,G.,Ruilope,L.,&Lucia,A.(2020).Exercisereducesambulatorybloodpressureinpatientswithhypertension:Asystematicreviewandmeta-analysisofrandomizedcontrolledtrials.
JournalofAmericanHeartAssociation,15(9),1-18.doi:10.1161/JAHA.120.018487.
Sakhuja,S.,Jaeger,B.C.,Akinyelure,O.P.,Bress,A.P.,Shimbo,D.,Schwartz,J.,&Muntner,P.(2022).PotentialimpactofsystematicandrandomerrorsinBPmeasurementontheprevalenceofhighofficeBPintheUnitedStates.
TheJournalofClinicalHypertension,24,263-270.
https://doi.org/10.1111/jch.1441
Schillinger,D.(2020).Theintersectionsbetweensocialdeterminantsofhealth,healthliteracy,andhealthdisparities.
StudiesinHealthTechnologyandInformatics,SocialDeterminantsofHealth,HealthLiteracy,andHealthDisparities,269,22–41.https://doi.org/10.3233/SHTI200020
Schober,P.,&Vetter,T.(2019).Descriptivestatisticsinmedicalresearch.
Anesthesia&Analgesia,129(6),1445-1447.https://doi.org/10.1213/ane.0000000000004480
Schwingshackl,L.,Chaimani,A.,Schwedhelm,C.,Toledo,E.,Pünsch,M.,Hoffmann,G.,&Boeing,H.(2019).Comparativeeffectsofdifferentdietaryapproachesonbloodpressureinhypertensiveandpre-hypertensivepatients:Asystematicreviewandnetworkmeta-analysis.
CriticalReviewsinFoodScienceandNutrition,59(16),2674-2687.doi:10.1080/10408398.2018.1463967.
Seals,D.,Nagy,E.,&Moreau,K.(2019).Aerobicexercisetrainingandvascularfunctionwithageinginhealthymenandwomen.
TheJournalofPhysiology,
597(19),4901-4914.
https://doi.org/10.1113/jp277764
Severin,R.,Sabbahi,A.,Albarrati,A.,Phillips,S.,&Arena,S.(2020).Bloodpressurescreeningbyoutpatientphysicaltherapists:Acalltoactionandclinicalrecommendations.
PhysicalTherapy,
100(6),1008–1019.
https://doi.org/10.1093/ptj/pzaa034
Shimbo,D.,Artinian,N.,Basile,J.,Krakoff,L.,Margolis,K.,Rakotz,M.,AmericanHeartAssociation,&AmericanMedicalAssociation.(2020).Self-measuredBPmonitoringathome:AjointpolicystatementfromtheAmericanHeartAssociationandAmericanMedicalAssociation.
Circulation,142(4),e42-e63.
https://doi.org/10.1161/CIR.0000000000000803
Smith,M.(2018).Theeffectsofregularaerobicexerciseonbloodpressureofadultswithhypertension
[Unpublisheddoctoraldissertation].GrandCanyonUniversity.
Song,C.,Xiahong,M.,Ning,X.,&Song,S.(2020).Nursingcasemanagementforpeoplewithhypertension:Arandomizedcontrolledtrialprotocol.
Medicine,
99(52),13. doi:10.1097/MD.0000000000023850
StatisticalSolutions.(2019).
Quasi-experimentalresearchdesigns.
https://www.statisticssolutions.com/quasi-experimental-research-designs/https://www.statisticssolutions.com/quasi-experimental-research-designs
Stergiou,G.,Asmar,R.,Myers,M.,Palatini,P.,Parati,G.,Shennan,A.,Wang,J.,O’Brien,E.,&EuropeanSocietyofHypertensionWorkingGrouponBloodPressureMonitoringandCardiovascularVariability.(2018).Improvingtheaccuracyofbloodpressuremeasurement:TheinfluenceoftheEuropeansocietyofhypertensioninternationalprotocol(ESH-IP)forthevalidationofbloodpressuremeasuremeasuringdevicesandfutureperspectives.
JournalofHypertension,36(3),479-487.doi:10.1097/HJH.0000000000001635.
SunTechMedical.(2021).Oscar2ambulatorybloodpressuremonitor.
https://www.suntechmed.com/bp-products/ambulatory-blood-pressure-monitoring/oscar-2-ambulatory-blood-pressure-monitor#features
Tagney,J.,Baumeister,R.,Boone,R.,&Luzio,A.(2004).Highself-controlpredictsgoodadjustment,lesspathology,bettergrades,andinterpersonalsuccess.
JournalofPersonality,72,271-322.doi:10.1111/j.0022-3506.2004.00263.x
Texas Department of State Health Services.(2022).
Timmers,T.,Janssen,L.,Stohr,J.,Murk,J.,&Berrevoets,M.(2020).UsingeHealthtosupportCOVID-19education,self-assessment,andsymptommonitoringinTheNetherlands:Observationalstudy.
JournalofMedicalInternetResearch,
8(6),1-10.
https://doi.org/10.2196/19822
U.S.CensusBureau.(2020).
HarrisCounty,Texasprofile.
https://data.census.gov/cedsci/all?q=Harris%20County
UTHealthScienceCenteratHouston.(2020).
TopHarrisCounty,Texas,areaswhereresidentsaremostlikelytoneedhospitalization,ICUcareforCOVID-19.
https://www.uth.edu/news/story.htm?id=f13ff981-c534-4b14-89eb-726e189f4e59#
Virani,S.,Alonso,A.,Benjamin,E.,Bittencourt,M.,Callway,C.,Carson,A.,Chamberlin,A.,Chang,A.,Cheng,S.,Delling,F.,Djousse,L.,Mitchell,S.,Elkind,V.,Ferguson,J.,Fornage,M.,Khan,S.,Kissela,B.,Knutson,K&Tsao,C.(2020).Heartdiseaseandstrokestatistics2020update:AreportfromtheAmericanHeartAssociation.Circulation,141(9),e139–596.https://doi.org/10.1161/CIR.0000000000000757
Wang,D.,Hatahet,M.,Wang,Y.,Liang,H.,Bazikian,Y.,&Bray,C.(2019).MultivariateanalysisofhypertensioningeneralUSadultsbasedonthe2017ACC/AHAguideline:datafromthenationalhealthandnutritionexaminationsurvey1999to2016.
BloodPressure,28(3),191-198.doi:10.1080/08037051.2019.1593042
Whelton,P.,Carey,R.,Aronow,W.,Casey,D.,Collins,K.,DennisonHimmelfarb,C.,De-Palma,S.,Gidding,S.,Jamerson,K.,&Jones,D.(2017).ACC/AHA/AAPA/ABC/ACPM/AGS/APhA/ASH/ASPC/NMA/PCNAguidelinefortheprevention,detection,evaluation,andmanagementofhighbloodpressureinadults:executivesummary:AreportoftheAmericanCollegeofCardiology/AmericanHeartAssociationTaskForceonclinicalpracticeguidelines.
Hypertension
,71
,1269–1324.
https://doi.org/10.1161/hyp.0000000000000076
Weiss,B.,Mays,M.,Martz,W.,Castro,K.,DeWalt,D.,Pignone,M.,&Hale,F.(2005).Quickassessmentofliteracyinprimarycare:Thenewestvitalsign.
AnnalsofFamilyMedicine,3(6),514–52210.1370/afm.405
Williamson,W.,Lewandowski,A.,Huckstep,O.,Lapidaire,W.,Ooms,A.,Tan,C.,Mohamed,A.,Alsharqi,M.,Bertagnolli,M.,Woodward,W.,Dockerill,C.,McCourt,A.,Kenworthy,Y.,Burchert,H.,Doherty,A.,Newton,J.,Hanssen,H.,Cruickshank,J.,McManus,R.,&Leeson,P.(2022).Effectofmoderatetohighintensityaerobicexerciseonbloodpressureinyoungadults:TheTEPHRAopen,two-arm,parallelsuperiorityrandomizedclinicaltrial.
EclinicalMedicine,
48,1-29.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eclinm.2022.101445
WorldHealthOrganization.(2021,August).
Hypertension.https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/hypertension
Yatim,M.,Wong,Y.,Neoh,C.,Lim,S.,Hassali,M.,&Hong,Y.(2019).Factorsinfluencingpatients’hypertensionself-managementandsustainableself-carepractices:Aqualitativestudy.PublicHealth,173,5-8.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.puhe.2019.04.020
Appendix A
GrandCanyonUniversityInstitutionalReviewBoardOutcomeDeterminationLetter
Appendix B
American Heart Association Physical Activity Guidelines
AppendixC
Permission to Use the American Heart Association Physical Activity Guidelines
image1.jpeg
image2.jpeg
image3.jpeg
image4.jpeg
Effectiveness of Aerobic Exercise on Ambulatory Blood Pressure in Hypertensive Patients
Presented by
Chinyere Christiana Pamugo
1
DNP 965: Final Oral Presentation
December 13, 2022
A Direct Practice Improvement Project Presented in Partial Fulfillment
of the Requirements for the Degree
Doctor of Nursing Practice
2
Investigator’s background
Registered Nurse for XXX years
3
Topic’s background
Many individuals are unaware of the symptoms for hypertension, which makes it a top priority to educate patients and their families.
In the United States, over 37 million individuals are affected (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2021; Krist et al., 2021).
The American College of Cardiology and the American Heart Association guidelines for hypertension management and definition of HTN defines it as having a blood pressure at or above 130/80 mmHg (The American College of Cardiology Foundation and the American Heart Association, 2018). At the same time, stage 2 HTN is blood pressure at or above 140/90mmHg (CDC., 2021).
4
Topic’s background
Complications of the condition include myocardial infarction, heart failure, chronic renal disease, and stroke (Ghatage et al., 2021).
American Heart Association Task Force (AHA) published new guidelines to help manage the increase of the disease (Wang et al., 2019).
Purpose statement
The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks
6
problem statement
It was not known if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients
7
Identified problem
At the clinical site, there were no standardized guidelines for clinicians to educate hypertensive patients regarding implementing daily physical activity as a blood pressure management mechanism.
Collaboration with the medical director and some of the nursing staff showed an increase of 37.1% in diagnosed HTN patients within the past six months. The clinic’s findings corresponded with the health statistics from the Texas Department of State Health Services (2022), as the county ranks 22 in the States with diagnosed hypertensive patients
8
Significance of the project
Implementing a recommended evidence-based strategy by the AHA guideline regarding aerobic exercise
Commodore-Mensah et al. (2018) state that the financial prices are significant, approximately $131-198 billion annually
This project could help decrease the financial costs associated with the disease
Hypertensive persons incur an extra $2000 yearly in healthcare expenditures compared to non-hypertensive persons (Commodore-Mensah et al., 2018).
9
Clinical question
To what degree does the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas?
The independent variable was the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research regarding aerobic exercise, and the dependent variable is blood pressure
10
Theoretical underpinnings
Dorothy Orem’s self-care deficit theory (Orem, 1995).
Kurt Lewin’s change model (Lewin, 1947).
Unfreezing
Change or Movement
Refreezing
Based on the theory, self-care is that patients must engage in to maintain and improve their quality of health (Orem, 1995). Utilizing this theory, the nurses do not see their patients as inactive or receiving health services; instead, they consider them strong and reliable to participate in daily activities and decision-making processes (Orem, 1995). Three nursing systems are defined in Orem’s nursing theory; they include wholly compensatory, partially compensatory, and supportive-educative strategies (Khademian et al., 2020).
The chosen change is Lewin’s change model. It was selected because it is a way to describe the process change versus guiding the activities that will be conducted.
11
review of the Literature
Prevention of Hypertension
Systolic Blood Pressure Management
Diastolic Blood Pressure Management
Ambulatory Blood Pressure Management
Aerobic Exercise Health Intervention
Pre-Aerobic State
Post-Aerobic State
Ambulatory Blood Pressure Management
Effect of Exercise on Blood Pressure
Health Literacy Level
Self-Efficacy
Lifestyle Modification
12
clinical Question
To what degree does the implementation of American Heart Association guideline aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas?
The independent variable is the American Heart Association guideline regarding aerobic exercise, and the dependent variable is blood pressures.
13
Methodology
Quantitative methodology
Using numerical data
It is objective, systematic, and focused data analysis strategies (Guetterman & Fetters, 2018).
Data can be replicated (Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
In this project, the project manager will evaluate the AHA guidelines and its impact on the blood pressures of HTN patients. The dependent variable will be measured four weeks before and post project intervention. This methodology is the most appropriate because other investigators can replicate the data (Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
A qualitative methodology was not selected because this method is often thematic and subjective, and findings are produced using the participants’ words verbatim (Creswell & Creswell, 2018). In this project, the project manager will not seek to understand the participants’ behaviors, feelings, or lived experiences (Creswell & Creswell, 2018
14
Project design
Quasi-experimental design
Determines the effect that the independent variable has on the dependent variable (Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
Participants are not randomly assigned (Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
Project manager will manipulate the independent variable
For this project, the dependent variable (blood pressure) will be measured at two different times (once before the intervention and one after the intervention (Creswell & Creswell, 2018). A correlational design was not the most appropriate for this project. It is a non-experimental design where the independent and dependent variables are measured and assessed for their correlation relationship (Creswell & Creswell, 2018).
15
Instrumentation
Data source: ABPM log retrieved from the Oscar 2 device
Electronic ABP data retrieved from the electronic medical record
Before starting the ABP project, it was imperative to ensure that the device operated as required and was installed correctly on the patient (Nwankwo et al., 2020).
The electronic ABP data on the device was retrieved from a computer via a USB cable
16
Data collection
Data collected four weeks pre/post implementation
Oscar 2 device
Participants walked at home three to five times weekly for 20 minutes
They were instructed to continue taking their antihypertensive medications
Tracked their process in a logbook (Mon, Wed, Fri)
Participants were re-evaluated at the clinic week four
The healthcare providers took the 24-hour ABP measurements at two-time points: baseline without aerobic exercise in week one and week four after the workout
In week four, the participants returned to the clinic to retake their ABP using Oscar 2 device. Participants ambulated around the clinic for 20 minutes wearing the Oscar 2 device. They were monitored for their walking, whether it was intense or moderate. The ABP measurements were taken after a 20-minute rest period by the staff.
17
Data analysis
Descriptive data (such as age, gender, and ethnicity)
Paired Sample t-Test.
Descriptive data (such as age, gender, and ethnicity) will be collected via the clinic’s electronic medical records (evaluated using frequency counts and percentages)
The independent variable is nominal, and the dependent variable is an interval level variable (Schober & Vetter, 2019). This t-test examines the mean scores taken from the same participants (Schober & Vetter, 2019).
The level of statistical significance was set to .05 to indicate that a p-value of less than .05 will be considered statistically significant.
18
results
Variable | Descriptive Data | |
M | SD | |
Age | 56.50 | 7.92 |
Table 1
Descriptive Data for Age
Table 2
Descriptive Data for Gender and Race
Variable | Descriptive Data | |
n | % | |
Gender | ||
Male | 3 | 30.0 |
Female | 7 | 70.0 |
Race | ||
African American | 8 | 80.0 |
Hispanic | 1 | 10.0 |
Caucasian | 1 | 10.0 |
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
Note. n =count; % = percentage
results
Variable |
Pre |
Post |
t (9) |
p |
||
M | SD | M | SD | |||
Systolic BP (mm/Hg) | 152.60 | 14.42 | 126.10 | 19.93 | 6.35 | .001 |
Chi-square test results showed a decrease in the mean systolic BP level from pre (M = 152.60, SD = 14.42) to post (M = 126.10, SD = 19.93), t (9) = 6.35, p = .001. The p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean systolic BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by the 26.50 mean decline in the systolic mean levels after the intervention.
Table 3
Paired t-Test Results for Systolic Blood Pressure Levels
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
results
Variable |
Pre |
Post |
t (9) |
p |
||
M | SD | M | SD | |||
Diastolic BP (mm/Hg) | 87.30 | 11.19 | 78.10 | 8.45 | 2.56 | .031 |
Chi-square test results showed a decrease in the mean diastolic BP level from pre (M = 87.30, SD = 11.19) to post (M = 78.10, SD = 8.45), t (9) = 2.56, p = .031. The p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean diastolic BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by the 9.20-point mean decline in the systolic mean levels after the intervention.
Table 4
Paired t-Test Results for Diastolic Blood Pressure Levels
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
limitations
Small sample size
Limited time frame to conduct project (four-weeks)
Data analysis being conducted by outside statistician
First limitation: Small sample size
Second limitation: Limited time (four-weeks) a longitudinal project three or more months
Third limitation: Due to the project manager’s limited knowledge and time in conducting statistical analysis, an outside statistician not affiliated with the project or manager will perform the data analysis.
22
discussion
Clinical significance was demonstrated by the 26.50 mean decline in the systolic mean and 9.20 in the diastolic mean and 9.20 in the diastolic mean levels
Based on the results, the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s on aerobic exercise may improve blood pressure. One recommendation for future projects is to conduct the project in other medical settings, such as medical-surgical units, women’s health, and dialysis patients.
Recommendations
The project findings showed that an educational program in combination with aerobic exercise about hypertension can result in systolic and diastolic blood pressure changes
Reproduce the intervention in other healthcare settings
Conduct longitudinal project (one year or longer)
For nurse managers to pay attention to the HTN risk in their older employees (age 40 and above)
Evaluate the patient’s health stressors that can contribute to hypertension
references
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, (2021). Facts about hypertension in the United States. https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/facts.htm
Commodore-Mensah, Y., Selvin, E., Aboagye, J., Turkson-Ocran, R., Li, X., Himmelfarb, C., Ahima, R., & Cooper, L. A. (2018). Hypertension, overweight/obesity, and diabetes among immigrants in the United States: An analysis of the 2010–2016 national health interview survey. BMC Public Health, 18(1), 1-8. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-018-5683-3
Creswell, J.W., & Creswell, J. D. (2018). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (5thed.). Sage Publications.
references
Ghatage, T., Goyal, S., Dhar, A., & Bhat, A. (2021). Novel therapeutics for the treatment of hypertension and its associated complications: Peptide- and nonpeptide-based strategies. Hypertension Research, 44(7), 740-755. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41440-021-00643-z
Guetterman, T., & Fetters, M. (2018). Two methodological approaches to the integration of mixed methods and case study designs: A systematic review. American Behavioral Scientist, 62, 900-918.
https://doi.org/10.1177/0002764218772641
Krist, A., Davidson, K., Mangione, C., Cabana, M., Caughey, A., Davis, E., Donahue, K., Doubeni, C., Kubik, M., Li, L., Ogedegbe, G., Pbert, L., Silverstein, M., Stevermer, J., Tseng, C., & Wong, J. (2021). Screening for hypertension in adults. JAMA, 325(16), 1650-1656. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.4987
references
Lewin, K. (1947). Frontiers in group dynamics: concept, method, and reality in social science; social equilibria and social change. Human Relations, 1, 5–41.
https://doi.org
/10.1177/001872674700100103
Nwankwo, T., Coleman King, S. M., Ostchega, Y., Zhang, G., Loustalot, F., Gillespie, C., & Merritt, R. (2020). Comparison of 3 devices for 24-hour ambulatory blood pressure monitoring in a nonclinical environment through a randomized trial. American Journal of Hypertension, 33(11), 1021-1029.https://doi.org/10.1093/ajh/hpaa117
Orem, D. E. (1991). Nursing: Concepts of practice (4th ed.). Mosby.
Schober, P., & Vetter, T. (2019). Descriptive statistics in medical research. Anesthesia & Analgesia, 129(6), 1445-1447. https://doi.org/10.1213/ane.0000000000004480
Wang, D., Hatahet, M., Wang, Y., Liang, H., Bazikian, Y., & Bray, C. (2019). Multivariate analysis of hypertension in general US adults based on the 2017 ACC/AHA guideline: data from the national health and nutrition examination survey 1999 to 2016. Blood Pressure, 28(3), 191-198. doi: 10.1080/08037051.2019.1593042
Effectiveness of Aerobic Exercise on Ambulatory Blood Pressure in Hypertensive Patients
By Chinyere Christiana Pamugo
Grand Canyon University, Phoenix Arizona
Introduction and Problem
Variables
Descriptive Data
Results
Results (cont.)
Clinical Question(s)
Discussion
Project Limitations
Recommendations for Future Projects and Practice
Purpose of the Project
Data Analysis
The project site is a primary care clinic in urban Texas. A convenience sample of n= 10 adult patients with HTN were enrolled in the project. Descriptive data were collected for age, gender, and race.
Table 1 displays the descriptive data for age. The mean age was 56.50 (SD = 7.92) ranging from 43 to 71.
References
The independent variable was the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research regarding aerobic exercise, and the dependent variable is ambulatory blood pressure.
.
.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). (2021). Facts about hypertension in the United States. https://www.cdc.gov/bloodpressure/facts.htm
Krist, A., Davidson, K., Mangione, C., Cabana, M., Caughey, A., Davis, E., Donahue, K., Doubeni, C., Kubik, M., Li, L., Ogedegbe, G., Pbert, L., Silverstein, M., Stevermer, J., Tseng, C., & Wong, J. (2021). Screening for hypertension in adults. Journal of the American Medical Association, 325(16), 1650-1656. https://doi.org/10.1001/jama.2021.4987
Leedy, P., & Ormrod, J. (2020). Practical research: Planning and design. Pearson Publications.
Saco-Ledo, G., Valenzuela, P., Ruiz-Hurtado, G., Ruilope, L., & Lucia, A. (2020). Exercise reduces ambulatory blood pressure in patients with hypertension: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Journal of American Heart Association, 15(9), 1-18. doi: 10.1161/JAHA.120.018487.
Many individuals are unaware of the symptoms for hypertension, which makes it a top priority to educate patients and their families.
In the United States, over 37 million individuals are affected (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], 2021; Krist et al., 2021).
Using the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressures.
At the clinical site, there were no standardized guidelines for clinicians to educate hypertensive patients regarding implementing daily physical activity as a blood pressure management mechanism
It was not known if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients
Chi-square test results showed a decrease in the mean systolic BP level from pre (M = 152.60, SD = 14.42) to post (M = 126.10, SD = 19.93), t (9) = 6.35, p = .001. The p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean systolic BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by the 26.50 mean decline in the systolic mean levels after the intervention. The results are displayed in Table 3.
The results are presented to address the clinical question related to the impact of the AHA guidelines for aerobic exercise on systolic and diastolic blood pressure. A paired t-test was conducted on systolic and diastolic blood pressure at pre-and post-implementation.. The goal was to reduce ambulatory blood pressure after the intervention. Results are displayed in narrative and table format.
The purpose of this quantitative, quasi-experimental project was to determine if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks
To what degree does the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas
Clinical significance was demonstrated by the 26.50 mean decline in the systolic mean and 9.20 in the diastolic mean and 9.20 in the diastolic mean levels
Based on the results, the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s on aerobic exercise may improve blood pressure. One recommendation for future projects is to conduct the project in other medical settings, such as medical-surgical units, women’s health, and dialysis patients.
The first limitation was the restricted time to conduct the project (four weeks). A longitudinal project allows one to evaluate the trends and changes over time (Leedy & Ormrod, 2020).
The second limitation was the small sample size. The primary problem with a small sample size was interpreting the results, mainly related to the confidence intervals and p-values (Leedy & Ormrod, 2020).
The project findings showed that an educational program in combination with aerobic exercise about hypertension can result in systolic and diastolic blood pressure changes
Reproduce the intervention in other healthcare settings
Conduct longitudinal project (one year or longer)
Nurse managers to pay attention to the HTN risk in their older employees (age 40 and above)
Evaluate the patient’s health stressors that can contribute to hypertension
Descriptive data (such as age, gender, and ethnicity) including mean and standard deviation for age and frequencies and percentage for gender and ethnicity.
To examine systolic and diastolic blood pressure at pre- and post-implementation, paired sample t-tests were conducted in IBM SPSS version 28 using a level of significance of .05.
Table 1
Descriptive Data for Age
Table 2
Descriptive Data for Gender and Race
Gender and race are displayed in Table 2. There were three males (30.0%) and females made up 70.0% (n = 7). Race was 80.0% (n = 8) African American, 10.0% (n = 1) Hispanic, and 10.0% (n = 1) Caucasian.
Table 3
Paired t-Test Results for Systolic Blood Pressure Levels
Chi-square test results showed a decrease in the mean diastolic BP level from pre (M = 87.30, SD = 11.19) to post (M = 78.10, SD = 8.45), t (9) = 2.56, p = .031. The p-value is less than .05 which indicates that the decrease in mean diastolic BP was statistically significant. Clinical significance was supported by the 9.20-point mean decline in the systolic mean levels after the intervention.
Table 4
Paired t-Test Results for Diastolic Blood Pressure Levels
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
Note. n =count; % = percentage
Note. M = mean; SD =standard deviation
TEMPLATE DESIGN © 2008
www.PosterPresentations.com
28
Statistics show that as at the end of 2010, an estimated 31.1% of adults (1.39 Billion) worldwide had hypertension, with many people unaware of its symptoms. This makes my projects unique as it is designed for educating patients and their families. As indicated above, complications from this health condition may include myocardial infarction, heart failure, chronic renal disease, and stroke (Ghatage et al., 2021).
Purpose of Study: My quantitative, quasi-experimental project determines if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise can impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients in a primary care clinic in southwest Texas over four weeks. The problem came from the fact that at the clinical site, there was no standardized guidelines for clinicians to educate hypertensive patients regarding implementing daily physical activity as a blood pressure management mechanism. It created a problem statement that “it was not known if or to what degree the translation of Saco-Ledo et al.’s research on aerobic exercise would impact ambulatory blood pressure when compared to current practice among adult hypertensive patients.”
The significance of this project stems from the fact there is the need to implement an evidence-based strategy such as the ones recommended by the AHA guideline regarding aerobic exercise as well as the recommendation of Commodore-Mensah et al. (2018), in which it states that spending on prices are significant and is approximately $131-198 billion annually. This project potentially helps in decreasing the financial costs associated with the disease when Dorothy Orem’s self-care deficit theory (Orem, 1995) and Kurt Lewin’s change model (Lewin, 1947)’s Unfreezing, Change or Movement and Refreezing are used.
Recommendations: The discovery in this projects proved that an educational program in combination with aerobic exercise about hypertension results in systolic and diastolic blood pressure changes. Other recommendations include:
Reproduce the intervention in other healthcare settings
Conduct longitudinal project (one year or longer)
For nurse managers to pay attention to the HTN risk in their older employees (age 40 and above)
Evaluate the patient’s health stressors that can contribute to hypertension
29
image1.jpeg
image2.jpeg
image3.png
image4.png
image5.jpeg
image6.png
image7.png
image8.png
image9.png
image10.jpeg
Are you stuck with another assignment? Use our paper writing service to score better grades and meet your deadlines. We are here to help!
Order a Similar Paper
Order a Different Paper
